"Is it fair?"- Fans divided over Billie Eilish’s shoutout for Abi Carter in American Idol

American Idol season 11 finalist Abi Carter
American Idol season 11 finalist Abi Carter (Image via Instagram/@americanidol)

American Idol season 22 aired its season finale on Sunday, May 19, 2024. During the segment, fans saw the top three take to the stage once again in an attempt to impress the judges and the country one last time with their vocals before one of them was crowned as the winner of the ABC singing competition.

During the live streamed segment, nine-time Grammy Award winner Billie Eilish gave one of the contestants, Abi Carter, a shoutout which was played out on screen. While Carter couldn't believe it and was beyond happy, fans of the show had mixed reactions about the same.

They took to social media to chime in on the segment.

"Is it fair that Abi gets a shoutout from Billie Eilish? Now a sh*t-ton of Eilish fans will be hypnotically voting for Billie and not for Abi as such. #AmericanIdol," one person wrote.
"#AmericanIdol as someone said, I don't think Marc Cuban doing a tape for Jack Blocker is going to get the amount of fans voting for him that Billie Eilish's did. But they had to TRY to disguise the favoritism and antics to ensure Abi's win," another person wrote.
"#AmericanIdol I can't believe how they're trying to skew the results for Abi. First win the screaming audience but then with a taped message from Billie Eilish. That's so unfair! It's going to get Billie's fans to vote for her!," A fan wrote.

Several American Idol season 22 fans were also thrilled by what they saw:

"Not Billie making me cry. Everyone vote for Abi on Idol. She auditioned with WWIMF and is in the finale. Text 8 to 21523 #AmericanIdol," one person wrote.
"THERE'S NO F*CKING WAY OH MY GOD BILLIE ABI YOU DESERVE THIS OH MY GOD #AmericanIdol," another person wrote.
"Billie Eilish surprised Abi on #AmericanIdol wishing her good luck ughhhhhhhh even Billie recognizes how big of a superstar Abi is going to be!!!!," a tweet read.

American Idol season 22 fans further wrote on X:

BILLIE EILISH SENDS A MESSAGE TO ABI CARTER THIS IS INSANE NOW GO ON AND WIN THE WHILE THING #AmericanIdol," one person wrote.
"Abi got that Billie edge over Jack, not fair. #AmericanIdol Now, I'm voting for Abi to win this thing.," another person wrote.

American Idol season 22 finale: Billie Eilish has a message for Abi Carter

In the American Idol season 22 finale, the top three performed one last time in an attempt to gather enough votes to win the ABC show. As part of the final segment, Bon Jovi served as a mentor for the remaining contestants, Abi Carter, Jack Blocker, and Will Moseley.

The episode started with the top three singing Livin' on a Prayer by Bon Jovi. Before the finale started, the contestants met up with the legendary singer to prepare and Abi told him she wanted to perform Bed of Roses.

He told her to copy his version and to sing it in her way. When she took to the stage, Bon Jovi praised her rendition and said she was "the whole package".

Katy Perry said:

The room may be cheering but if you're not voting from home it doesn't mean anything, so you better vote.

The American Idol season 22 finalist was then informed that she had a special message. A video message from Eilish was then played for her.

"I love you so much. I wish you nothing but the best, and I just can't wait to see what happens tonight. I'm here to support you forever," Eilish said.

American Idol season 22 finale is currently streaming on ABC.

Quick Links

App download animated image Get the free App now