Ranking the 5 worst managers in Manchester United history

David Moyes was one of Manchester United's worst managers.
David Moyes was one of Manchester United's worst managers.

Manchester United has been home to some of the greatest footballers and managers in the history of the sport. However, following the departure of Sir Alex Ferguson, United have failed to find a suitable replacement for their most successful manager.

Since 2013, The Red Devils have appointed five different managers with as many different playing styles and tactics. However, none of that has seemed to work at Old Trafford, with the latest incumbent Ole Gunnar Solskjaer poised to become the next casualty. The Norwegian is yet to win a trophy with Manchester United thus far, and recent results have been poor, to say the least.

On that note, here's a look at the five worst managers in Manchester United's history.


#5 Ole Gunnar Solskjaer

Ole Gunnar Solskjaer might be sacked in the coming months.
Ole Gunnar Solskjaer might be sacked in the coming months.

Despite being perilously close to the exit door on multiple occasions, Ole Gunnar Solskjaer has retained his job as Manchester United manager.

Following a disappointing run of results in the last few months, the Manchester United legend is under threat of losing his job. According to reports, Zinedine Zidane is likely to be the man to replace the Norwegian at Old Trafford. Most Manchester United fans would happily trade Solskjaer for Zidane at the moment, as the Norwegian has been ineffective and naive with his tactics and approach.

Following Jose Mourinho's dismal two-and-a-half-year spell at Manchester United, Solskjaer was assigned the role of interim manager. He enjoyed a flying start to the second innings of his Manchester United career, and was appointed permanent manager soon thereafter.

The 48-year old has done a solid job of rebuilding the Manchester United squad, instilling some of the core values of the historic club. Solskjaer healed the dressing room morale, which was left fractured by Mourinho.

However, Solskjaer might have reached the end of his managerial ceiling, as he has failed to take the next big step at Manchester United. The Norwegian has been pivotal in rebuilding United, but winning a trophy with his former club might be a bridge too far.


#4 Jose Mourinho

Jose Mourinho was underwhelming as Manchester United boss.
Jose Mourinho was underwhelming as Manchester United boss.

Jose Mourinho got off to a flying start in his Manchester United career, winning three trophies in his first season in charge at the club.

The Portuguese's winning mentality and pedigree perfectly complemented a European powerhouse like Manchester United. Mourinho took over the reins at Old Trafford in the summer of 2016. He signed the likes of Paul Pogba, Henrikh Mkhitaryan, Zlatan Ibrahimovic and Eric Bailly in his first transfer window as United boss.

Having spent over £165 million in his first transfer window, Mourinho was expected to challenge for the Premier League and Champions League titles. The 2016-17 season was a positive start in that direction, but things went only downhill from there. The Portuguese failed to land a single trophy in his second year at the club before getting sacked midway into his third season.

Mourinho achieved decent results during his time at Manchester United, but he was heavily criticised for his defensive approach and man-management skills. He fell out with the likes of Paul Pogba, and the dressing room morale was at an all-time low. The Portuguese left the team in a far worse condition than when he inherited it.

#3 Frank O'Farrell

Frank O'Farell had a forgettable stint as Manchester United manager.
Frank O'Farell had a forgettable stint as Manchester United manager.

Frank O'Farrell had the impossible job of replacing Sir Matt Busby, taking over the reins at Manchester United in the summer of 1971.

The Red Devils were one of the most dominant clubs in European football at the time, winning the European Cup three years before Farrell's arrival. There were huge expectations on O'Farrell as he became the first and only Irishman to be appointed Manchester United manager.

In his debut season in charge, O'Farrell led United to first spot in the First Division for a brief period. That was the first time the Red Devils secured the top spot in three years. However, O'Farrell soon fell out with some of the biggest names in United's dressing room, including the likes of George Best.

The Irishman was provided £500,000 to rebuild the squad, which was an extremely high amount at the time. However, O'Farrell failed to achieve the desired results, and was sacked after a 5-0 loss to Crystal Palace.

In 56 matches as Manchester United manager, O'Farrell registered 21 wins, 14 draws and 21 losses for a dismal win percentage of 37.0.


#2 Louis Van Gaal

Louis Van Gaal was sacked two days after winning the FA Cup.
Louis Van Gaal was sacked two days after winning the FA Cup.

After securing a third-place finish for Netherlands at the 2014 FIFA World Cup, Louis van Gaal took over as manager of Manchester United.

The Dutchman signed the likes of Angel Di Maria, Luke Shaw, Radamel Falcao and Ander Herrera in his first season in charge. He spent over £165 million in his first transfer window. With some world-class talents in his ranks, Van Gaal enjoyed the board's full backing. However, he was extremely underwhelming in his two-year spell at Manchester United.

Van Gaal won only one trophy at Old Trafford - the 2015-16 FA Cup title. However, he was sacked just two days later, failing to mount a substantial challenge for the Premier League title.

The Dutchman did not endear himself to the Manchester United faithful with his bland playing style, and the club failed to achieve the desired results.

In his debut Premier League season in charge of United, Van Gaal's side were in ninth place with 13 points and three victories after ten games. That was Manchester United's worst start to a season since 1986-87 under Ron Atkinson.

In 103 matches as Manchester United boss, Van Gaal secured 54 wins, 24 draws and 25 losses.


#1 David Moyes

David Moyes has exceeded expectations at West Ham.
David Moyes has exceeded expectations at West Ham.

David Moyes is the first among a host of managers who have struggled at Manchester United following Sir Alex Ferguson's departure.

Dubbed 'The Chosen One', Moyes took over the reins at Old Trafford in the summer of 2013. He was personally named by Sir Alex Ferguson as his long-term replacement following an impressive 11-year spell with Everton. At the time, Moyes was regarded as one of the most talented managers in the continent. But he never hit the ground running at Manchester United.

The Scotsman could never fill the big shoes of Sir Alex Ferguson, and looked out of depth during his nine-month spell at Old Trafford. Moyes did not really receive the backing of the Manchester United board, making only two signings in his first transfer window in charge.

In 51 matches as Manchester United manager, David Moyes had a record of 26 wins, ten draws and 15 losses. He had a dismal win record of just over 50%, and was replaced by Ryan Giggs, who took over as the interim manager.

Quick Links

App download animated image Get the free App now