10 best anime to watch if you like Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister

Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister has quickly become one of the most popular romantic comedy anime since its premiere in 2024. Centered around Uryū Kamihate and his relationships with the three Amagami sisters, this heartwarming show perfectly balances hilarious moments with emotional drama and unique cultural themes related to shrine life.

For those who love Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister and want similar anime to enjoy, this list has them covered! From romantic comedies full of complex love polygons to stories about unexpected relationships in unusual circumstances, these 10 anime all capture a similar feeling.

Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in the article are those of the author.

10 best anime for fans of Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister

1. Quintessential Quintuplets

Quintessential Quintuplets (Image via Tezuka Productions)

Perhaps the most obvious recommendation, Quintessential Quintuplets follows high school tutor Fuutarou Uesugi as he is hired to improve the grades of the five Nakano sisters.

What starts off as a contentious academic relationship soon leads to emerging feelings between Fuutarou and the sisters. Much like in Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister, the Nakano sisters each have their distinct personalities and challenges they are overcoming.

As Fuutarou interacts more with them, complex romantic relationships develop. With five potential love interests, comedic moments, and emotionally powerful drama, Quintessential Quintuplets is an excellent pick for fans.

2. We Never Learn: Bokuben

We Never Learn: Bokuben (Image via Studio Silver and Arvo Animation)

For another great harem rom-com option, look no further than We Never Learn: Bokuben.

It follows Yuiga Nariyuki, a broke student on a scholarship, who must tutor three gifted but academically challenged girls—Fumino, a literature lover bad at math; Rizu, a science genius struggling with arts; and Uruka, a swimmer weak in all subjects.

Much like in Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister, Yuiga develops close relationships with multiple girls—Fumino, Rizu, Uruka, and more—leading to quite the entanglement and plenty of comedy. With a light tone punctuated by more emotional moments as bonds deepen, Bokuben makes another fantastic choice.

3. Rent A Girlfriend

Rent A Girlfriend (Image via TMS Entertainment)

For a series that explores relationships forming from unusual circumstances, look no further than Rent A Girlfriend. Heartbroken after being dumped, university student Kazuya Kinoshita rents Chizuru Mizuhara through an app to act as his girlfriend.

But when his family mistakes Chizuru for his real lover, they continue the charade to avoid complications. Just like in Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister, where Uryū enters a non-traditional relationship for unique reasons, Kazuya’s feelings for Chizuru develop early, while her emotions stay ambiguous and grow gradually.

With similar themes of unusual relationships that lead to humor and drama, fans of Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister are sure to enjoy this unexpected rom-com as well.

4. Oreshura

Oreshura tells the comedic love story of Eita Kidō, an academically gifted high schooler focused on becoming a doctor to support his single-parent family.

But his school life changes dramatically when the beautiful but narcissistic Masuzu Natsukawa suddenly proposes they fake a relationship to keep other boys from pestering her. What starts as a rom-com grows into romantic entanglements in Oreshura, not unlike Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister.

While it has harem-like elements, the series primarily focuses on Eita and Masuzu’s fake dating dynamic. As side characters emerge with their own crushes on Eita, bonds are formed along with all the expected romantic chaos. The initial fake dating premise also mirrors Uryū’s situation quite closely.

5. Love Hina

Another classic series Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister fans need to see is Love Hina. After failing his university entrance exams twice, Keitaro Urashima travels to his grandmother’s inn, which has since been transformed into a girls’ dormitory.

With a childhood promise driving him, Keitaro takes up the manager job and interacts with tenants Naru, Motoko, and others, leading to hilarious and heartfelt moments. Centered around one hapless guy surrounded by potential love interests, much like Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister, the parallels are clear.

With Keitaro helping the girls work through issues while dealing with his own shortcomings and dreams, real bonds and even love emerge from the antics and arguments. For one of the genre's most iconic classics, be sure to check out Love Hina next.

6. Nisekoi

For another fan favorite harem comedy dripping with intrigue, look no further than Nisekoi. When high schoolers and fake lovebirds Chitoge and Raku are spotted together, they are pressured by feuding mob families into maintaining their false relationship much longer than intended.

With fake relationships turning to real affection in unusual circumstances yet again, Nisekoi should seem plenty familiar for Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister fans. As Chitoge, Kosaki, Marika, and more all emerge with growing feelings for Raku, constantly surprising events unfold against the mob backdrop.

And with secrets still lurking from Raku’s past, Nisekoi delivers nonstop entertainment.

7. Shuffle!

Shuffle! provides a romance-packed supernatural option for Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister fans, following Rin Tsuchimi when he moves into a neighborhood where gods, demons, and humans coexist.

He soon catches the eye of several female classmates while uncovering more about their connections to his life. With another average guy catching the attention of multiple gorgeous love interests with unique backgrounds, the appeal for Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister viewers is clear.

While humor and romance drive the story, Shuffle! also explores darker themes of jealousy, tragedy, and mental health struggles. For a series with a similar structure but an exciting mystical twist, be sure to watch Shuffle!.

8. Domestic Girlfriend

Domestic Girlfriend (Image via Diomedéa)

For a more mature take on unexpected relationships getting complicated, Domestic Girlfriend is just the ticket. The romantic drama begins when teacher-in-training Natsuo Fujii has a one-night stand with Rui Tachibana, only to later discover she becomes his step-sister after his father remarries.

Things only get more chaotic when he falls for Rui’s older sister, Hina, his teacher. With mature themes of romantic entanglements involving step-siblings—not unlike Uryū navigating affection for the Amagami sisters—this series adds plenty of sensational drama.

As bonds form and painful choices emerge, Natsuo’s relationships create no shortage of gripping romantic storylines for viewers.

9. My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU

My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU (Image via Brain's Base, and Feel)

While more comedically focused than dramatic, My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU nonetheless bears strong similarities to Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister as cynic Hachiman Hikigaya navigates a tangled web of relationships that help him re-examine his worldview.

Forced to join the Service Club by his teacher where he meets exceptional student Yukino Yukinoshita, the story explores their unexpectedly growing bond. Much like Uryū in Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister, Hachiman forms nontraditional relationships with atypical “love interests” that soon lead to real emotional growth.

And with multiple characters taking an interest in Hachiman over time, this turning point in his youth should feel quite familiar.

10. Citrus

Lastly, there is Citrus, a highly melodramatic yuri series rife with taboo relationships and personal growth. It follows model student Yuzu Aihara as her mother remarries, leading to Yuzu transferring into a strict elite academy where her cold new stepsister Mei happens to be student council president.

As they are forced to share close quarters, hostility morphs into passion. With stepsiblings entering an unexpected and forbidden relationship that leads to deeper bonds, like Uryū and the Amagami sisters, Citrus explores similar territory albeit with more intensity and mature themes.

With drama galore as personalities clash and trauma lurks in the past, get ready for laughs, tears, and fist-clenching tension.

Conclusion

For fans hungry for more appealing anime rom-coms after falling for Tying the Knot with an Amagami Sister, options luckily abound.

From popular picks like Quintessential Quintuplets and Nisekoi to critically acclaimed classics such as Shuffle! or genre-bending fare like Citrus, series bursting with chaotic relationships offer no shortage of amusement and meaningful connections to enjoy.