In the One Piece universe, endless mysteries exist where legends emerge from unexpected origins, and the impossible becomes possible. Marshall D. Teach, who operates under the alias Blackbeard, remains one of the most baffling personalities in the series.
No character has ever exhibited Blackbeard's ability to control multiple Devil Fruit powers, leaving fans and fellow characters puzzled as it breaks essential rules of the One Piece world. Perhaps Blackbeard's unique abilities stem from an unknown heritage that questions established Devil Fruit knowledge rather than a mystical explanation.
Disclaimer: This article is a speculative theory and reflects the writer's opinion.
Unraveling the multi-heartbeat mystery in One Piece
The theory that Blackbeard belongs to a rare Three-Hearted Race offers a fascinating perspective to examine his extraordinary power. In a world filled with diverse races like Giants, Three-Eyed individuals, and Fishmen, the notion of a multiple-hearted race goes beyond simple speculation.
The World Government's history of suppressing powerful and unique races lends credibility to the idea that Blackbeard's origins may have been intentionally concealed. Central to this theory is the groundbreaking idea that the heart is a vessel for Devil Fruit powers.
Also read: Blackbeard may have a major connection to Imu (but not how One Piece fans think)
Traditional understanding suggests that the power of a Devil Fruit becomes bound to an individual upon consumption. However, this new perspective proposes that the heart is the true vessel for these supernatural abilities. The potential of each heart to hold a unique Devil Fruit power explains Blackbeard's remarkable ability to acquire multiple abilities.
Blackbeard’s multiple hearts in One Piece: A theory on power and will
While the evidence for this theory remains indirect, it still carries an element of fascination. The Blackbeard Pirates' systematic use of sharp weapons against Devil Fruit users demonstrates their strategic plan to collect power. Thatch's bloody demise and the attempted knife attack on Sabo suggest a method of power extraction that goes beyond conventional understanding.
Vegapunk's revelation that Devil Fruits manifest human desires adds another layer of complexity to this theory. If desires originate from the heart, and Devil Fruit powers are extensions of human will, then multiple hearts could indeed equate to multiple power reservoirs.
Also read: One Marine Admiral will likely revolt against One Piece's Celestial Dragons (& it's not Akainu)
This connects directly to the concept of Haki as a manifestation of spirit, suggesting that Blackbeard's multiple hearts might represent multiple independent wills. The narrative hints are compelling.
Luffy and Zoro's early perception of Blackbeard as something more than a single entity—sensing multiple beings or presences—now takes on profound significance. What if they were literally sensing multiple heartbeats, multiple souls contained within one body?
Blackbeard’s dream in One Piece: Ambition and Limitless Power
The meaning of Blackbeard's principle—"A man's dream will never die"—gains more significance when examined in this context. He doesn't simply gather powers because he becomes the literal representation of other people's dreams and wills. The Devil Fruits he absorbs reflect his boundless ambition, physically demonstrating his ability to surpass established limits.
If this theory holds true, it elevates Blackbeard from a mere villain to a complex symbol of human potential. He becomes a character who literally embodies multitudes, challenging the very boundaries of what is possible in the One Piece world.
Also read: Oda misled fans about Loki's Devil Fruit, and latest One Piece spoilers all but confirm it
According to the Three-Hearted Race theory, power requires more than brute strength; it demands the ability to absorb diverse viewpoints and convert those understandings into transformative action.
In conclusion

Throughout the ongoing One Piece saga, Blackbeard is a mysterious and formidable presence among the series' characters. His dual Devil Fruit power defies established rules, prompting an examination of his unique body structure and the fundamental properties of Devil Fruits.
Blackbeard's cunning strategy, relentless ambition, and patient nature separate him from other pirates, establishing him as a fearsome force on the high seas. The enigmatic nature of Blackbeard’s ultimate objectives ensures that his story will continue. His involvement in the latest saga will redefine our perceptions of power structures while exploring identity and the essence of this remarkable world.
Also read
- Luffy won't use his Devil Fruit at all against Blackbeard (& it's obvious why)
- Loki's redemption arc officially begins in latest One-Piece spoilers
- 5 best openings to One Piece arcs (& the 5 worst), ranked
- Usopp's Elbaph Arc opponent may be a Holy Knight (& parallel one of his best fights)