Chainsaw Man chapter 189's second Fumiko may explain her contradictive character so far

Modified Jan 09, 2025 09:30 GMT

New chapter's revelations might explain her contrasting character (Image via MAPPA)

Chainsaw Man chapter 189 was another mind-blowing addition to the story by creator Tatsuki Fujimoto. Following the previous chapter's events, the fandom was on the edge of their seats. In true Fujimoto fashion, the chapter delivered a shocking twist by revealing a second Fumiko Mifune, potentially unraveling the mystery behind her contradictory behavior throughout the series.

For quite a while, fans have wondered about Fumiko’s conflicting actions. The moments she showed compassion were juxtaposed with cold indifference. As such, her readiness to make morally dubious sacrifices (10,000 children sacrifice) was on the radar. In chapter 189, such discrepancies might have a plausible reason: two Fumikos with distinct personalities and motivations.

Needless to say, this revelation has led to another bout of speculation—a theory centered on these two Fumikos and their odd natures.

Disclaimer: This article is speculative in nature.

Chainsaw Man: New chapter's revelations might explain her contrasting character

Expand Tweet

In brief, Chainsaw Man chapter 189 revealed Denji as a pathway between the real world and Aging's world. Through his mouth, Yoshida and Yoru unsuccessfully attempted to attack the Aging Devil. The chapter also appalled viewers by showcasing two Fumiko Mifunes.

Initially, Fumiko Mifune sided with the Aging Devil, offering herself to power its attacks. But as she lay dying, another Fumiko appeared, expressing her (twisted) glee at siding with the likely winner. The surprises weren't over as the first Fumiko offered her heart to Yoshida and, in turn, the Octopus Devil.

All this fueled a recent theory that there were always two Fumikos — each with different personalities. Moreover, it was these two Fumikos who acted contrastingly and confused fans.

The theory speculates that one was likely a Denji fan, and the other loved Chainsaw Man. This would explain her urge to protect Denji and her coldness toward him. There is also speculation that Fumiko might possess some kind of Devil power that activated when she was at death's door, which would explain how a second version of her appeared.

Could there really be two Fumikos?

The prospect of a double in Chainsaw Man certainly sounds intriguing. Two Fumikos appearing in the latest chapter add fuel to the chaos about what can and cannot be expected next. The theory that the two distinct Fumikos have different personalities and worldviews is fascinating to read.

However, when looking at the chapter closely, other conclusions can be drawn. For instance, what if this isn't another Fumiko, but rather Fumiko's thoughts being displayed? In simpler terms, she might be having a dialogue with herself where she reveals her desire to side with the party that could likely win. This would explain why she suddenly offered her heart to Yoshida.

Moreover, she must have understood that Denji and the company figuring out the situation probably placed them better in defeating the Aging Devil. The trio of Chainsaw Man, Yoru, and the Octopus Devil was quite powerful, at least to Fumiko. Again, being from Public Safety herself, alongside Yoshida, and earlier tasked with Denji's protection, she likely offered her.

Overall, it feels more like an internal monologue than a duplicate. After all, no one acknowledged the double except her, which further emphasizes this statement.

Final thoughts

The revelations of Chainsaw Man chapter 189 open the door to intriguing possibilities. It could point to the existence of two Fumikos operating as per their separate wills or an odd Devil power that Fumiko is hiding. Either way, it leaves much room for speculation, inviting fans to piece together the implications of a development like this.

As mentioned, the idea of a duplicate does seem intriguing. But again, it is unlikely that Fujimoto would choose such a route at this point. It involves too many loose ends and would require a dedicated explanation later in the storyline. Judging by the chapter itself, Fumiko having an internal dialogue sounds more plausible and fitting for the present situation.

Related links:

Edited by Shreya Das