How the humanity of Anime Villains makes them popular

Humanity, in any character, brings them to life and makes them relatable to the audience, and Anime Villains are no exception. Villains with tragic backstories, in particular, tend to evoke sympathy from viewers, adding more depth to their personas.

Whether it's iconic antagonists from series like Naruto, Attack on Titan, Demon Slayer, My Hero Academia, or others across the vast animanga universe, fans often encounter villains whose actions, while unjustifiable, are rooted in circumstances that offer an understanding of their motivations.

These complex characters stand in stark contrast to stereotypical, psychopathic antagonists who commit evil just for the sake of it. By revealing their human sides, these villains transcend the label of "absolute evil," becoming more memorable and popular among audiences who can empathize with their motivations and causes.

The allure of tragic backstories in making Anime Villains beloved

Itachi is one of the most tragic anime villains (Image via Pierrot)

The anime universe is filled with villains whose tragic backgrounds and heart-wrenching backstories set them apart. Beyond their pasts, many of these antagonists also reveal moments of kindness and, in some cases, even undergo redemption arcs.

These glimpses into their human sides not only add complexity to their characters but also bring emotional depth to the overall narrative. Such nuanced portrayals explore the multifaceted nature of human emotions and morality, compelling viewers to rethink their initial perceptions of these characters.

What starts as disdain for these villains often transforms into empathy, as audiences come to understand the motivations behind their actions. This shift in perception often results in these characters achieving widespread popularity among fans.

Examples of some of the most tragic yet popular Anime Villains

Expand Tweet

Some of the most iconic examples can be found in a single Shonen, which adopts this approach for many of its antagonist characters.

In Naruto, villains like Itachi, Pain, Madara, and Obito initially appeared as detestable foes. However, as their backstories unfold, their humanity and underlying struggles become evident, earning them sympathy and admiration from fans. Zabuza and Haku also embody this duality. Despite their undeniable acts of villainy, their sympathetic backstories and motivations resonate deeply.

Zabuza's ambition to better his village and Haku's loyalty, his ultimate sacrifice to protect Zabuza, followed by Zabuza's heartfelt final actions driven by his love for Haku, further humanize them. These moments mark their place as complex, memorable characters among fans.

Examples of such complex and tragic villains are abundant even outside Naruto. In My Hero Academia, both Tomura Shigaraki and Dabi come from backgrounds marked by trauma and neglect, which drive them toward paths of destruction and revenge.

Even Shigaraki's villainous journey is ultimately revealed to be a result of All For One's manipulation. Similarly, other members of the League of Villains, including Himiko Toga, Twice, and Spinner, each have deeply tragic backstories that set them on their dark paths.

Villains like Meruem from Hunter x Hunter epitomize moral complexity, challenging viewers to confront profound ethical dilemmas. In Fairy Tail, Zeref Dragneel's struggles with immortality and overwhelming regrets transform him into a villain.

Akaza has one of the most tragic backstories among anime villains (Image via Ufotable)

The Promised Neverland introduces Isabella, whose entire life is a tragedy. Her desire to protect the children under her care is at odds with the cruel system forcing her to send them to their deaths, casting her as a villain despite her deeply human motives.

Likewise, Demon Slayer features several villains with pitiable and tragic backstories. Gyutaro and Daki, Akaza, Rui, though initially portrayed as loathsome demons, ultimately evoke sympathy from the audience as their pain and sufferings reveal the circumstances that led them astray.

The new anime Dandadan presents some of the most intricate and tragic villain backstories, earning significant sympathy from the fandom.

The connection between tragic villains and human emotions wins fans over

Expand Tweet

These are just a few examples from the extensive list of anime villains whose human sides have made them immensely popular. All these tragic backstories and emotional depth not only elicit empathy but also elevate these characters to iconic status within their respective franchises, turning them into some of the most popular anime villains.

While their actions remain indefensible, their struggles compel viewers to reflect on their circumstances, consider the world from their perspective, and ponder what choices they might have made in similar situations. This deeper understanding sheds light on how cornered these characters may have felt, leading them to spiral into villainy.

By challenging the simplistic black-and-white view of good versus evil, such narratives encourage viewers to explore the gray areas, fostering a greater awareness of the complexities of human emotions and moral dilemmas.

Final thoughts

Dabi is one of the most tragic and popular anime villains (Image via Bones)

These factors are what truly distinguish these anime villains from the typical antagonists driven solely by evil agendas, like Jujutsu Kaisen's Sukuna or My Hero Academia's AFO. While these sympathetic villains are becoming more common in modern storytelling, some fans now see it as almost inevitable, waiting for the moment when their human sides are revealed.

While this narrative choice remains engaging for many, offering nuanced storytelling, it can also risk becoming a predictable trope. The overuse of these elements— once responsible for creating some of the most beloved and complex anime villains— could eventually strip the concept of its originality and reduce the versatility of antagonist characters.