Naruto fan's Kaguya/Imu comparison has One Piece fans outraged

Recently, a Naruto enthusiast's comparison between the formidable Kaguya from Naruto and the enigmatic Imu from One Piece sparked a whirlwind of controversy across social media platforms. This sparked a fiery debate among the ardent One Piece fanbase, igniting a clash of perspectives and unwavering loyalty.

Comparisons between characters from distinct fictional universes are not uncommon among dedicated fans. These spirited exchanges often arise from a deep appreciation for the intricate narratives, complex character arcs, and captivating storytelling woven throughout these beloved series.

Naruto fan compares Kaguya's lackluster introduction to that of Imu from One Piece

Expand Tweet

A Naruto fan going by the name of @Chidori_Uchiha_ sparked controversy on X. When other fans pointed out certain points, the user failed to consider the significant time difference between the introductions of Kaguya and Imu. By comparing the reception of these characters without acknowledging this key aspect, this fan misinterpreted the reasons behind the differing fan reactions.

Kaguya Otsutsuki (Image via Studio Pierrot)

The final antagonist in the epic Naruto saga, Kaguya Otsutsuki, emerged just 21 chapters before the series concluded. Her introduction in chapter 679 felt hasty compared to previous villains with more backstory build-up.

Many fans felt dissatisfied, as they didn't have enough time to understand Kaguya's character fully. They pointed out how antagonists like Pain or Obito, motivations were explored in-depth, but Kaguya's sudden appearance lacked the same level of character development.

Silhouette of Imu (Image via Toei Animation)

Imu, the central villain in One Piece, first appeared in chapter 906, a substantial 205 chapters before the current events. The introduction of this character was skillfully crafted to create an air of mystery and intrigue. The chilling and eerie atmosphere surrounding Imu's debut piqued readers' curiosity about this enigmatic individual.

How the One Piece fandom replied to this comparison between the two antagonists

"I told him, I told him to delete it. Now a quote ratio and 10K on his head somebody save him" a Naruto fan jokingly tweeted

"Both are false, neither kaguya nor Imu were revealed out of nowhere" as per a fan who follows both the series

"Kaguya has been hinted at. people (one piece fans) just want to be spoon fed" defended a Naruto fan

The tweet comparing Kaguya from Naruto to Imu from One Piece sparked a strong reaction. Fans expressed frustration, seeing it as an attempt to stir up conflicts between fandoms. They argued the characters' introductions and development differed drastically, making comparisons unfair.

Some felt the tweet lacked basis, fueling unnecessary animosity between communities meant to appreciate their respective series.

"Imu isn’t out of nowhere because he/she still hasn’t been fully revealed, and is just a shadowy figure. Kaguya came on the spot. The 5 elders were revealed pre timeskip" according to a One Piece fan

"He's a Naruto fan, he's just ruining the One Piece community by agenda. Oda is unpredictable, so if you think imu is the final villain, you don't understand Oda's story and writing. Black Beard is the most likely final villain and as for imu hasn't been fully revealed yet and she/he creates a huge villain aura even before he's fully revealed, so don't compare imu to Kaguya" a fan wrote

"No that doesn’t work as a counter argument there’s literally more arcs after the introduction and the story literally isn’t over and not ending in 30-40 chapters. So hopefully this wasn’t just for engagement" a concerned fan said

For over twenty years, One Piece has captivated audiences with its intricate storytelling and lovable characters.

Fans have grown deeply attached to this epic tale. So when criticism surfaced, they rallied to defend their cherished series. Their backlash stemmed from a protective bond and appreciation for the meticulous world-building. The fandom's fierce loyalty couldn't let any critique go unchallenged.

Final thoughts

Kaguya Otsutsuki when she first arrived on Earth (Image via Studio Pierrot)

The discussion around comparing Kaguya and Imu from the Naruto and One Piece series highlights the passionate nature of fandoms. Fans love analyzing characters and plots.

However, overlooking key details, like the time gap between Kaguya and Imu's introductions, can lead to misunderstandings. Context is crucial when making comparisons between different stories. While fans may have strong opinions, considering all relevant information is essential to avoid conflicts and promote respectful dialogue within the community.

About the author

Abhinand has been an anime writer at Sportskeeda for close to a year. Currently completing his Bachelor’s degree in Transportation Technology, it is his love for the genre that motivated him to become a writer. He has been watching anime for a few years and is eager to delve deeper into the domain.

Abhinand has previously worked as a medical writer and believes it is crucial to cross-check every piece of news using multiple sources of information to ensure most accurate and relevant reporting.

Abhinand enjoys watching movies and brands Al Pacino and Irrfan Khan as ‘different class of actors’ for their ability to bring narratives to life. When not working, he plays basketball and binges on the latest web series and anime releases.

Know More

Edited by Toshali Kritika