Why should there be a Black Butler season 5? Explored

The anticipation surrounding Black Butler season 5 has been fever-pitch, especially after the epic conclusion of season 4. The franchise returned after years to enthrall fans with the Public School Arc, where Ciel and Sebastian investigated a peculiar case in Weston College. While they resolved the case, fans want to see more of the beloved duo.

Although the official staff hasn't green-lit Black Butler season 5 yet, there's a good chance the anime might return. Those who follow the manga would know that the story is far from over, and season 4's ending hinted that the anime could return with the adaptation of the next major arc.

Aside from that, the reception of the latest season can also compel the official staff to have the Black Butler season 5 green-lit for production. Follow along with this article to know why Ciel Phantomhive and Sebastian Michaelis could return for another season.

---

Exploring the reasons why Black Butler season 5 should be green-lit for production

Produced by Cloverworks, Black Butler season 4 was a brilliant sequel that spellbound the fandom after years. The latest season saw Ciel Phantomhive and his butler, Sebastian Michaelis, investigate a strange case in London's Weston College, where several students had gone missing.

Undoubtedly, the latest season captivated fans with the faithful adaptation of Mangaka, Yana Toboso's original dark fantasy manga.

That said, fans want to know whether Black Butler season 5 is around the corner. As mentioned, the latest season ended on a cryptic note, leaving scope for a sequel. The anime's ending saw the inception of a new case in Germany, where two noblemen confronted a werewolf-like creature in a forest.

The werewolf-like creature in season 4's final episode (Image via Cloverworks)

Manga readers would know that the ending scene in the recently concluded season teases the Emerald Witch Arc, the next major arc of Yana Toboso's manga, after the Public School Arc. This particular arc begins in chapter 86 and continues til chapter 107.

Given how Cloverworks ended the latest season with the teaser of Emerald Witch Arc, fans have every reason to believe that Black Butler season 5 could be green-lit for production in the future, and it would adapt the major arc, where Ciel Phantomhive and Sebastian Michaelis undertake another strange case on Queen's request.

Besides, there's enough source material for Black Butler season 5. Yana Toboso's manga series has published 213 chapters thus far, and the anime has only covered 86 chapters up to the latest season.

Ciel Phantomhive and his butler, Sebastian (Image via Cloverworks)

With more than double amount of chapters left for adaptation, source material won't be a problem for production. As a result, Cloverworks or any other studio can even consider making Black Butler season 5 a two-cour series without worrying about source material's scarcity.

Moreover, the official staff can also green-light season 5, based on the audience feedback. The latest season has a rating of 7.96/10 on MyAnimelist, with 69,215 members (as of this writing). Undoubtedly, the rating and member list speak volumes about the season's success and popularity.

Lastly, the Public School Arc's anime adaptation was pleasantly faithful to the manga. Cloverworks has done an exceedingly decent job of portraying the iconic panels in animated form while adding subtle anime-only sequences to elevate the manga.

This can bode well for Black Butler season 5, which, if it gets green-lit, would cover the Emerald Witch Arc, one of the fan-favorite arcs in the series. If Cloverwork returns to produce the series for a fifth season, fans could expect the same treatment as season 4.

---

Final thoughts

Ciel, as seen in the anime (Image via Cloverworks)

In the end, it all comes down to the decision of the official staff, whether or not they want to produce Black Butler season 5.

However, considering how the latest season ended and the reception the series has gotten, fans can keep their hopes up. Undoubtedly, fans would love to see Ciel and Sebastian back into action again.

---