Why is the Violet Evergarden anime so controversial? The issue of age gap and love, explained

Violet Evergarden anime premiered in 2018 and quickly gained popularity in the community due to its plot and animation. Despite having only 13 episodes, this drama-fantasy show’s widespread acclaim led to the release of a side-story movie in 2019 and a sequel film in 2020.

Adapted from the Japanese light novel series written by Kana Akatsuki and illustrated by Akiko Takase, the series features an emotional storyline. However, the central plot revolves around the love between the main protagonist, Violet Evergarden, and Major Gilbert Bougainvillea, which has sparked controversy among viewers.

The significant age difference between the characters has become a point of discussion and debate within the fan community.

---

Violet Evergarden anime: Analyzing the controversial love between Major Gilbert and Violet due to their age gap

The central theme of the Violet Evergarden anime revolves around the relationship between Violet and Major Gilbert. It is also the very topic that puts the series under scrutiny from many fans.

Violet's precise age remains uncertain due to her origins as an orphan. However, a conversation with Princess Charlotte in the anime’s fifth episode suggests that she is around 14 years old. On the other hand, Major Gilbert, Violet’s former military superior, is supposedly 29 years old. This creates a notable age difference of 15 years between the two characters.

The age difference between Violet and Major Gilbert has become a focal point of discussion among fans, generating widespread dissatisfaction. Many viewers have voiced their concerns about the portrayal of love between a 14-year-old girl and a 29-year-old man, deeming this storyline development as unsettling and disturbing.

---

A brief synopsis of Violet Evergarden anime to grasp the underlying problem

Gilbert talking with young Violet in Violet Evergarden anime (Image via Kyoto Animation)

The story of Violet Evergarden anime follows Violet Evergarden, an ex-soldier, and her journey to self-discovery while adapting to her new life as an auto memory doll. She joins a postal company to assist others in expressing their emotions through writing letters and to understand the significance of her superior Major Gilbert Bougainvillea's final words.

Despite the significant age difference, Gilbert harbors a deep affection for Violet. Initially, Violet struggles to comprehend his emotions, but eventually, she comes to realize his sentiments.

Gilbert taking care of young Violet (Image via Kyoto Animation)

In her journey, she discovers the meaning of the Major’s parting words, “I love you," before his apparent demise in the war, Violets comes to realize she reciprocates Gilbert’s feelings. It's worth noting that the initial narrative does not explicitly clarify whether Gilbert's feelings for Violet are rooted in romantic interest or simple affection for the young girl.

As Major Gilbert makes a return in Violet Evergarden: The Movie (2020), the unfolding narrative strongly suggests that the connection between them has transitioned into a romantic relationship.

When Princess Charlotte inquired about Violet's perspective on an appropriate age difference in a romantic relationship, Violet asserted that love cannot be determined by age.

Therefore, her response, coupled with various instances throughout Violet Evergarden anime's narrative, makes it clear that she reciprocates Gilbert's romantic feelings.

It should also be noted that during the era depicted in the narrative of Violet Evergarden anime, substantial age gaps in relationships were prevalent, particularly among royalty. This trend is exemplified by Princess Charlotte and Prince Damien, who also share a considerable age difference of 10 years.

Violet with Gilbert in the war (Image via Kyoto Animation)

Nevertheless, viewing the developments from contemporary standards, it's comprehensible why their relationship might raise concerns among some fans. It is especially so given that when Major Gilbert conveyed his emotions, Violet was only 14 years old.

That said, in Violet Evergarden: The Movie (2020), when they eventually reunite, a substantial amount of time has passed since their initial separation. At this time, Violet is assumed to be around 18 years old at that point.

---

Stay tuned for more anime and manga news in 2024.