Has a rookie ever been an All-Star MLB?

Last Modified Jul 12, 2024 06:05 GMT
Has a rookie ever been an All-Star MLB
MLB All-Star (Source: Getty Images)

The Major League Baseball All-Star Game is held each year and the best players are chosen from both the National League and American League. It is also known as the Midsummer Classic and is usually played on the second or third Tuesday of July.

Selecting members of the Major League Baseball All-Star Game team involves a detailed and structured process. The fan votes pick starting fielders and respective team managers select pitchers. Players and managers then vote for the reserves in order to ensure that the best of each league’s players make it onto the field.

List of Rookies who have played in MLB All-Star Games

Several rookies have managed to become an MLB All-Star during the history of Major League Baseball. Joe DiMaggio holds the record for the youngest MLB All-Star Rookie ever. He became an All-Star MLB in 1936 at 21 years of age. Throughout his baseball career, he has been with the New York Yankees for 13 years and a 13-time MLB All-Star, the first time being as a rookie in 1936.

In addition, Frank Robinson appeared in Major League Baseball All-Star as a rookie in 1956. Robinson started in 1956 with the Cincinnati Redlegs/Reds picked him to be part of the All-Star team. For the duration of his Major League Baseball career, which spanned twenty-one years, he was selected to play in fourteen All-Star games.

Here is the list of rookie players who have been an All-Star in Major League Baseball:

YearPlayerTeam
1936Joe DiMaggioNew York Yankees
1956Frank RobinsonCincinnati Reds
1959Willie McCoveySan Francisco Giants
1964Tony OlivaMinnesota Twins
1975Fred LynnBoston Red Sox
1981Fernando ValenzuelaLos Angeles Dodgers
1984Dwight GoodenNew York Mets
1993Mike PiazzaLos Angeles Dodgers
2001Ichiro SuzukiSeattle Mariners
2001Albert PujolsSt. Louis Cardinals
2010Jason HeywardAtlanta Braves
2012Mike TroutLos Angeles Angels
2017Aaron JudgeNew York Yankees
2018Shohei OhtaniLos Angeles Angels
2019Yordan ÁlvarezHouston Astros
2019Pete AlonsoNew York Mets

What determines MLB Rookie eligibility?

In Major League Baseball (MLB), rookie eligibility is determined by a set of criteria established by the MLB Players Association and Major League Baseball. To be considered a rookie, a player must meet the following criteria:

1. Including the present season, a sportsman shall not have more than 130 at-bats or even 50 innings pitched in the major leagues.

2. Before September 1st year prior, a player is not to have stayed 45 days long in a major league team’s list.

3. Before the previous season, no player should have been listed on 40-man rosters by September 1.

When the following conditions are met, a player becomes a rookie for the season. Rookies can be determined per season; therefore, one player may qualify as a rookie in one year but not in the next. For players and teams, it may affect the player’s chances of winning certain awards such as Rookie Of The Year.

FAQ's On All-Star MLB

A. MLB All-Stars are selected through a voting process that includes fan votes, player ballots, and selections made by the All-Star managers.

A. The first MLB All-Star Game was held in 1933 at Comiskey Park in Chicago, Illinois.

A. The location of the MLB All-Star Game rotates annually among different Major League Baseball stadiums.

A. The youngest player to be named an MLB All-Star was Dwight Gooden of the New York Mets, who was 19 years old when he made his All-Star debut in 1984.

Related Stories

Yankees' $162M star relates to Devin Williams’ struggles in 2025 season Yankees' $162M star relates to Devin Williams’ struggles in 2025 season
Yankees' $162M star relates to Devin Williams’ struggles in 2025 season
Bobby Witt Jr. pulls off rare rookie card in epic trade with retired police officer Bobby Witt Jr. pulls off rare rookie card in epic trade with retired police officer
Bobby Witt Jr. pulls off rare rookie card in epic trade with retired police officer
Astros vs. Brewers: Game 3, prediction, odds, injuries and picks - May 7, MLB 2025 Astros vs. Brewers: Game 3, prediction, odds, injuries and picks - May 7, MLB 2025
Astros vs. Brewers: Game 3, prediction, odds, injuries and picks - May 7, MLB 2025
1d
Giants vs. Cubs: Game 3, prediction, odds, injuries and picks - May 7, MLB 2025 Giants vs. Cubs: Game 3, prediction, odds, injuries and picks - May 7, MLB 2025
Giants vs. Cubs: Game 3, prediction, odds, injuries and picks - May 7, MLB 2025
1d
Will Manny Machado enter MLB's Hall of Fame? Top insider lays out Padres superstar's credentials Will Manny Machado enter MLB's Hall of Fame? Top insider lays out Padres superstar's credentials
Will Manny Machado enter MLB's Hall of Fame? Top insider lays out Padres superstar's credentials
"We had our ups and downs" - When Derek Jeter opened up about his relationship with Alex Rodriguez and Yankees teammates "We had our ups and downs" - When Derek Jeter opened up about his relationship with Alex Rodriguez and Yankees teammates
"We had our ups and downs" - When Derek Jeter opened up about his relationship with Alex Rodriguez and Yankees teammates
1d
Carlos Rodon's wife Ashley shares adorable moment of Yankees star painting with son Silo Carlos Rodon's wife Ashley shares adorable moment of Yankees star painting with son Silo
Carlos Rodon's wife Ashley shares adorable moment of Yankees star painting with son Silo
1d
Astros manager Joe Espada reveal ‘good news’ on Yordan Alvarez injury status Astros manager Joe Espada reveal ‘good news’ on Yordan Alvarez injury status
Astros manager Joe Espada reveal ‘good news’ on Yordan Alvarez injury status
1d
Houston Astros vs Milwaukee Brewers Game 3 Player Stats and Box Scores for May 7 Houston Astros vs Milwaukee Brewers Game 3 Player Stats and Box Scores for May 7
Houston Astros vs Milwaukee Brewers Game 3 Player Stats and Box Scores for May 7
1d
From Max Verstappen as Barry Bonds to Charles Leclerc as Bryce Harper: McLaren CEO names MLB counterparts for F1 superstars From Max Verstappen as Barry Bonds to Charles Leclerc as Bryce Harper: McLaren CEO names MLB counterparts for F1 superstars
From Max Verstappen as Barry Bonds to Charles Leclerc as Bryce Harper: McLaren CEO names MLB counterparts for F1 superstars
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications