The New York Knicks filed a protest with the NBA following their controversial loss to the Houston Rockets on Tuesday. The Knicks are looking to become just the seventh team to have a successful protest, but when did the last successful NBA protest happen?
According to Robert Bradley at the Association for Professional Basketball Research, the last time an NBA protest was upheld was during the 2007-08 season. It was when the Miami Heat protested Shaquille O'Neal getting incorrectly disqualified from the game on Dec. 19, 2007.
Table officials at the game against the Atlanta Hawks got Shaq's number of fouls wrong. He was removed from the game with 59.1 seconds remaining in overtime when the Hawks' statistical crew thought that he had six fouls when he had five.
The league allowed the final 59.1 seconds of the game to be replayed on March 8, 2008. O'Neal was no longer with the Heat at that point and was traded to the Phoenix Suns. The original result was a win for the Hawks, and it remained a win after the replay.
Explore the NBA Draft 2024 with our free NBA Mock Draft Simulator & be the GM of your favorite NBA team.
What happened between the New York Knicks and Houston Rockets?
The New York Knicks visited the Houston Rockets on Tuesday, and the game was close until the end.
It was supposed to go to overtime, but Jalen Brunson was called for a foul on Aaron Holiday with about a second left. Holiday made two of his three free throws to give the Rockets a 105-103 win.
The NBA's L2M report confirmed that Brunson did not commit a foul, and it should have been a no-call. That meant that the Knicks could have won the game in overtime. Game crew chief and referee Ed Malloy confirmed that the contact between Brunson and Holiday was marginal and should not have been called a foul.
The L2M report and Malloy's comments were enough for the Knicks to file a protest with the NBA. The only question is whether the league will uphold the protest.
How many protests have the NBA upheld?
The New York Knicks have a slim chance of getting their protest upheld by the NBA. It has been 16 years since the league upheld a protest, so Knicks fans might not be happy heading into the break.
There have only been six successful protests in NBA history. Here's the list:
- 1952-53 season - Milwaukee Hawks vs. Philadelphia Warriors (Incorrect player substitution)
- 1969-70 season - Atlanta Hawks vs. Chicago Bulls (Disallowed buzzer-beater)
- 1971-72 season - Cleveland Cavaliers vs. Buffalo Braves (Cleveland not given a full timeout)
- 1978-79 season - New Jersey Nets vs. Philadelphia 76ers (Three technical fouls on a coach)
- 1982-83 season - Los Angeles Lakers vs. San Antonio Spurs (Double lane violation)
- 2007-08 season - Miami Heat vs. Atlanta Hawks (Statistical crew error)
Rockets Fan? Check out the latest Houston Rockets depth chart, schedule, and roster updates all in one place.