MS Dhoni or Rohit Sharma - who is the greatest IPL captain of all-time?

There is certainly much truth to the famous cricketing cliche - 'A captain is only as good as his team'. Yet, a select few captains can make a side rise above themselves and maximize their individual and collective potential - a category two of IPL's most celebrated captains, MS Dhoni and Rohit Sharma fit perfectly in.

The duo boasts of contrasting leadership styles. Rohit is more expressive and gives viewers a chance to see who is all about, while Dhoni is the master of keeping his cards close to his chest. Yet, the result has been the same - incredible success for their respective franchises, Chennai Super Kings (CSK) and Mumbai Indians (MI).

After setting an improbable benchmark, both the veteran cricketers handed the captaincy reigns to their successors last IPL season. And yet, uniquely, Dhoni and Rohit's captaincy prowess was enhanced even as they did not lead their respective franchises in IPL 2024.

Both teams missed the playoffs with their unceremonious early exits, prompting the CSK and MI fan bases to wish for a miraculous yet unlikely return of the duo as captains in IPL 2025.

Nevertheless, as Dhoni and Rohit continue to thrill fans with their batting heroics in the upcoming seasons, it is time to settle the ever-growing debate of who is the greatest IPL captain between the two once and for all.

---

#1 Raw numbers

IPL 2023: Final - Chennai Super Kings v Gujarat Titans - Source: Getty

Not many will deny the fact that MS Dhoni is the greatest IPL captain when it comes to any and every counting statistic. The 43-year-old is the league's most successful captain with 133 wins in 226 outings, with a winning percentage of 58.84.

Not only is Dhoni the only captain to lead his side in over 200 IPL games, but he is also the only skipper with 100 wins. Hence, the combination of longevity and success rate speaks volumes about Dhoni's inimitable and masterful leadership skills.

Coming to Rohit, the 37-year-old is no slouch when it comes to numbers with 87 wins in 158 matches as captain. His winning percentage of 55.06 is also extremely impressive in a league where almost all the participating teams are evenly matched on paper.

Both have led their sides to five IPL titles - the most in league history. It indicates their unmatched ability to make their teams perform on the big stage.

Yet, Rohit is second to Dhoni in each of the above-mentioned individual captaincy numbers, which combines experience and success.

Advantage: MS Dhoni

---

#2 Consistency vs Peak

2019 IPL Final - Mumbai v Chennai - Source: Getty

GOAT debates between any two legends of a sport often come down to two elements - who was more consistent for longer vs. who had a higher peak. And this is where the MS Dhoni - Rohit Sharma captaincy debate picks up steam.

Even with the dismal 2016 season captaining the Rising Pune Supergiant (RPS) and the 2022 campaign where he captained CSK for only the second half, Dhoni boasts a remarkable consistency record. The wicketkeeper-batter has led his sides to the playoffs in each of his first eight seasons as captain from 2008 to 2015.

While the consistency tapered off a touch in the second half of his captaincy career, Dhoni still led his sides to the playoffs in four out of the next seven seasons from 2016 to 2023 (He did not lead RPS in 2017).

Furthermore, Dhoni also led his side to at least the final in an incredible 10 out of his 15 seasons at the helm.

Unfortunately for Rohit, these numbers pale in comparison with Dhoni as he led MI to the playoffs in seven out of his 11 seasons as captain. While leading a side to the top four in over 60 percent (almost 64) is nothing to sneeze about, Dhoni's 80% playoff qualification rate as skipper is substantially higher.

While Rohit has led the side to the final am impressive five out of 11 seasons as captain, the 45.5 percent is much lower than Dhoni's 66.7.

Yet, the former MI skipper achieved a better peak through his captaincy career compared to the more consistent Dhoni. While CSK's best stretch under Dhoni was winning three titles in six seasons between 2018 and 2023, Rohit's five titles in eight seasons between 2013 and 2020 is nothing short of remarkable.

Hence, with the choice between consistency and peak being highly subjective, there is no right or wrong when it comes to this category. However, Dhoni's win as a captain in the consistency department is much higher than Rohit's edge in terms of peak performance. It means should the two carry equal weightage, the CSK skipper emerges victorious.

Advantage: MS Dhoni

---

#3 Head-to-Head

2019 IPL Final - Mumbai v Chennai - Source: Getty

MS Dhoni and Rohit Sharma have battled each other several times as captains between 2013 and 2023. While their head-to-head is about as even as it gets, the latter holds a slim 12-10 advantage in 22 encounters (MI vs CSK and MI vs RPS).

Yet, where Rohit undeniably trumps Dhoni is his ability to outdo the master tactician in the more meaningful playoff and final games.

Rohit boasts an incredible 11-4 record in 15 IPL playoff games with a winning percentage of 73.33. On the other hand, Dhoni's record sits at 17-9 in 26 playoff outings with a winning percentage of 65.38.

Further enhancing Rohit's case in the head-to-head matchups is his incredible 3-0 record vs Dhoni in IPL finals - 2013, 2015, and 2019. Rohit's 5-0 record as captain in IPL finals also indicates his clutchness come the big games.

Advantage: Rohit Sharma

---

Conclusion

Much like any closely-fought sports debate, the MS Dhoni-Rohit Sharma IPL captaincy debate will likely be a never-ending one for years to come. If consistency and reliability are your preferred flavors, then Dhoni walks away with the 'greatest captain' title.

However, should big-game prowess and higher peaks be the key performance indicators, Rohit certainly gets the nod over Dhoni. Yet, combining all of these factors in equal parts for the sake of this discussion, it would be hard to choose anyone over MS Dhoni as the 'Greatest IPL Captain', even if Rohit Sharma is undeniably his closest challenger.