Resident Evil 4 remake vs. Silent Hill 2 remake: Differences and similarities explored

Resident Evil 4 remake and Silent Hill 2 remake are undoubtedly two of the most iconic modern remakes of classic horror games. For decades, fans have been discussing the similarities between the originals, and now as the Silent Hill 2 remake nears its official release, the community is pulling a lot of parallels between the games.

In this article, we have discussed some of the key differences between the titles that set them apart as well as some similarities that the Resident Evil 4 remake and Silent Hill 2 remake share.

---

Differences and similarities between Resident Evil 4 remake Silent Hill 2 remake

RE 4 is more action while SH 2 is all about horror (Image via Capcom)

Action vs tension between Resident Evil 4 remake and Silent Hill 2 remake

From a gameplay perspective, Resident Evil 4 remake takes a more action-oriented approach compared to Silent Hill 2. RE4 is better known for its fast-paced combat, gunplay, and fast-paced movements. The third-person camera providing an over-the-shoulder perspective was a revolutionary shift for the franchise in the original game. Its remake also includes quick-time events and interactive environmental elements.

In contrast, the Silent Hill 2 remake focuses less on combat and more on exploration and puzzle-solving. While James Sunderland, the protagonist, fights against nightmarish monsters in the fog-covered town of Silent Hill, the focus is never on the action but on atmosphere, discovery, and dread-building. Many fans were concerned that the remake would stray from the original and make it an action game. Fortunately, this is not the case.

---

Story and Atmosphere differences between Resident Evil 4 remake and Silent Hill 2 remake

You will find pure dread in SH 2's atmosphere (Image via Konami)

When it comes to storytelling, the Silent Hill 2 remake features a lot of psychological complexity. The game's plot revolves around James Sunderland, who is drawn to Silent Hill after receiving a letter from his deceased wife, Mary. The town itself is a manifestation of James' guilt, pain, and repressed emotions.

As you progress, the story reveals dark secrets about James' past, making Silent Hill 2 a deeply personal narrative that explores themes of grief, guilt, and punishment. The monsters James encounters, including the iconic Pyramid Head, are symbolic manifestations of his inner torment.

On the other hand, the Resident Evil 4 remake features a more straightforward action-adventure narrative. Set in rural Spain, the plot follows Leon S. Kennedy, a U.S. government agent, tasked with rescuing the President’s daughter, Ashley Graham, from a dangerous cult called Los Iluminados.

---

Combat and Resource Management mechanics in Resident Evil 4 remake and Silent Hill 2 remake

SH2 doesn't give much focus on weapons or combat (Image via Konami)

In the Resident Evil 4 remake, combat is a primary focus. Leon is equipped with a variety of firearms and melee moves, and the game allows players to shoot guns, interact with the environment to kill enemies, and execute finishing moves on weakened enemies. The attache case inventory system gives you more flexibility in managing weapons and items, which can be upgraded or purchased through the Merchant.

However, the Silent Hill 2 remake places less emphasis on combat and resource management. James has access to a small selection of melee weapons and firearms, but he is far from a combat specialist. The restricted combat mechanics and lack of powerful weapons reinforce James' vulnerability, making you feel weak and isolated.

---

Visual similarities between Resident Evil 4 remake and Silent Hill 2 remake

Many say Leon and Jeremy are brothers from different mothers (Image via Capcom)

While both games are drastically different from one another in various aspects, we can’t ignore the fact that they share a lot of similarities when it comes to visuals. The character designs of James and Leon are very similar; even in the remakes, many fans have said that the protagonists of both of these games look very similar.

Other than the appearance of the protagonists, the gameplay loop, art style, and camera perspective are quite similar to each other. If you eliminate the eerie fog of the Silent Hill Town, it will look very similar to the village you visit in Resident Evil 4.