EPL 2016/17: Manchester City vs Manchester United Combined XI

MANCHESTER, ENGLAND - APRIL 16: David De Gea of Manchester United looks on during the Premier League match between Manchester United and Chelsea at Old Trafford on April 16, 2017 in Manchester, England.  (Photo by Michael Regan/Getty Images)
Speculation surrounds David De Gea’s future

Manchester City and Manchester United will face off in the Manchester Derby tonight, with both clubs desperate to secure a place in next season's Champions League. The two Manchester giants sit fourth and fifth respectively, with many people considering their seasons as underachievement and failures.

Nonetheless, one thing is for certain, and that is both sides possess an array of talented players with potential that knows no bounds. Enormous transfer fees have been spent by both sides to rope in some of the world's best attacking and defensive talents, but just what exactly would be deemed the best starting eleven from both squads?

Each team has a number of weaknesses but an abundance of strengths, so it's time to piece together a combined Manchester XI made of players from the two teams. Do you agree with the selections made?


Goalkeeper

David de Gea – Manchester United

Spanish international David de Gea was the overwhelming choice for the goalkeeping position with both Claudio Bravo and Willy Caballero some distance off the Spaniard's world-class levels.

The United shot-stopper has claimed more than 96% of his crosses he's attempted to come for as opposed to Claudio Bravo's pitiful 86% with 46% of them resulting in him punching the ball instead of catching the ball.

De Gea has also kept 13 clean sheets in 31 games with Bravo claiming just 5 in 21 games - conceding on average more than a goal per game. De Gea overcomes Bravo having averaged more than two saves per game resulting in him being the unanimous choice in goal.

Defenders

RB: Antonio Valencia – Manchester United

MANCHESTER, ENGLAND - APRIL 16:  Jose Mourinho manager of Manchester United signals as Antonio Valencia of Manchester United takes a throw in during the Premier League match between Manchester United and Chelsea at Old Trafford on April 16, 2017 in Manchester, England.  (Photo by Shaun Botterill/Getty Images)
Valencia has been instrumental for United this campaign

When United entered the season with Matteo Darmian as their right-back, many feared for their defensive strength for the whole campaign.

Mourinho opted to play winger Antonio Valencia in the role, and the Ecuadorian international has thrived in the position. With both Bacary Sagna and Pablo Zabaleta drastically underperforming, Valencia is the outstanding candidate for the right-back position.

Staggeringly, Valencia makes on average four defensive interceptions per game while also adding an attacking threat having created 27 key passes leading to an opportunity on goal.

CB: Vincent Kompany – Manchester City

LONDON, ENGLAND - APRIL 23:Vincent Kompany (R) of Manchester City is consoled by manager Josep Guardiola (C) during the Emirates FA Cup Semi-Final match between Arsenal and Manchester City at Wembley Stadium on April 23, 2017 in London, England.  (Photo by Julian Finney/Getty Images,)
Captain Vincent Kompany has been the inspiration for City in years gone by

Manchester City captain Vincent Kompany has returned to the playing eleven in recent weeks and already instilled a confidence and security to this ageing and fragile backline.

Injuries have destroyed the Belgian leader over the past three years but since returning to the first-team, Kompany has guided City to three clean sheets in five games. Also, his form hasn't dipped and with the player averaging four defensive interceptions weekly, he remains head and shoulders above everyone else.

CB: Eric Bailly – Manchester United

MANCHESTER, ENGLAND - APRIL 16: Eric Bailly of Manchester United is put under pressure from Diego Costa of Chelsea during the Premier League match between Manchester United and Chelsea at Old Trafford on April 16, 2017 in Manchester, England.  (Photo by Michael Regan/Getty Images)
Bailly pocketing Costa at Old Trafford a fortnight ago

The hardest decision was to choose a partner for Vincent Kompany in this side, but statistics don't lie and Eric Bailly's season guarantees him a spot in the eleven.

Little was known about the Ivorian when he signed for United last July, but his contribution has been sensational; meaning he edges Nicolas Otamendi and John Stones out of contention.

Bailly, unlike Stones' four mistakes, has not made a single error leading to a goalscoring opportunity all campaign. The player also averages a whopping nine defensive clearances per game. (Mourinho's system plays a major factor in that statistic).

LB: Aleksandar Kolarov – Manchester City

HUDDERSFIELD, ENGLAND - FEBRUARY 18: Aleksandar Kolarov of Manchester City during the the Emirates FA Cup Fifth Round match between Huddersfield Town and Manchester City at John Smith's Stadium on February 18, 2017 in Huddersfield, England.  (Photo by Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images)
Guardiola has certainly obtained the best of Kolarov’s form

Much like Antonio Valencia, little was expected of Aleksandar Kolarov at the beginning of the season as predictions were made that his future lay elsewhere. Nonetheless, the Serbian defender has been an integral part of Guardiola's backline and remained the club's most consistent defender.

Kolarov averages a total of eight interceptions per game and his attacking nature hasn't decreased in quantity. He has still managed a stunning 11 key passes this campaign when his prominent position has seen him feature at centre-back. With Luke Shaw's lack of form, and Matteo Darmian being played out of position, Kolarov is the ideal candidate at left-back.

Midfielders

CM: Fernandinho – Manchester City

LONDON, ENGLAND - APRIL 23: Fernandinho of Manchester City and Alexis Sanchez of Arsenal compete for the ball during the Emirates FA Cup Semi-Final match between Arsenal and Manchester City at Wembley Stadium on April 23, 2017 in London, England.  (Photo by Julian Finney/Getty Images,)
Fernandinho has been City’s most consistent performer all season

Both teams undeniably have outstanding issues with a holding midfield role, but Fernandinho is certainly the best-placed player for this spot in the team owing to a variety of reasons.

Unlike Paul Pogba, Ander Herrera, or Ilkay Gundogan, a number eight role suits their style much more than Fernandinho's whose relentlessness and tough tackling nature ensure City have something of a balance in midfield.

Fernandinho's poor discipline during the mid-season has caused his duel winning percentage to spiral down to 43% - a relatively weak statistic compared to his usual high standards.

CM: Paul Pogba – Manchester United

BURNLEY, ENGLAND - APRIL 23:  Paul Pogba of Manchester United battles for the ball with Robbie Brady of Burnley during the Premier League match between Burnley and Manchester United at Turf Moor on April 23, 2017 in Burnley, England.  (Photo by Gareth Copley/Getty Images)
Pogba fending off the onrushing Robbie Brady last weekend

Much has been made of Paul Pogba's world-record move to Manchester United with many considering him a failure after ten months in English football. An argument could be made to state Pogba's influence has been limited, but the player has indeed had a solid season.

The France international has registered 55 chances for his team-mates, three of which have resulted in an assist. Defensively, Pogba is the ideal candidate for the number eight role with him winning 54% of the duels he's contested for. His passing accuracy of 85% could still do with some improvement if he’s to develop into that player everyone once admired.

CAM: Kevin De Bruyne – Manchester City

LONDON, ENGLAND - APRIL 23: Kevin De Bruyne of Manchester City controls the ball under pressure of Laurent Koscielny of Arsenal  during the Emirates FA Cup Semi-Final match between Arsenal and Manchester City at Wembley Stadium on April 23, 2017 in London, England.  (Photo by Mike Hewitt/Getty Images,)
De Bruyne attempts to hold off Laurent Koscielny on Sunday

Kevin De Bruyne may not be having his strongest season in recent times, but that further highlights the Belgian international's credentials.

Nonetheless, De Bruyne has still mustered more chances for his side than any other player in the Premier League this season. In fact, De Bruyne's 85 chances is already an upgrade on last season's 79. The Belgian has also registered 17 assists in all competitions - making that 31 in just two seasons at City.

De Bruyne has still managed to score six goals across all competitions, and as mentioned, this is apparently his worst season in three years?

Attackers

RW: Leroy Sané – Manchester City

MANCHESTER, ENGLAND - APRIL 08: Leroy Sane of Manchestr City  shoots during the Premier League match between Manchester City and Hull City at Etihad Stadium on April 8, 2017 in Manchester, England.  (Photo by Shaun Botterill/Getty Images)
Sané is gathering quite a reputation

Raheem Sterling, Leroy Sané, Henrikh Mkhitaryan or Juan Mata? Unfortunately for ever other name mentioned, Sané must be placed in this combined team for his inherent world-class ability along with his output since obtaining his place in the City first-team.

Likened regularly to Gareth Bale, Sané has become a big game player for City this season as his displays against the top five since December have been sensational. Sané has managed to score 10 goals since December, being the focal point of City's attack.

The German has the potential to become far superior to any other player mentioned above.

LW: Anthony Martial – Manchester United

BURNLEY, ENGLAND - APRIL 23:  Jose Mourinho, manager of Manchester United shakes hands with Anthony Martial of Manchester United as he is substituted during the Premier League match between Burnley and Manchester United at Turf Moor on April 23, 2017 in Burnley, England.  (Photo by Jan Kruger/Getty Images)
Martial coming off after a brilliant display against Burnley

Just four goals for Anthony Martial has been somewhat disappointing considering his superb debut campaign under Louis van Gaal. However, one thing that cannot be denied is Martial has arguably more potential than any other forward player in this United side.

His first season at United saw him score a whopping 17 goals for his new club following a £58 million move from AS Monaco. This campaign, despite creating a chance per game, and providing five assists, Martial has played fewer minutes than any other United attacker in the first-team.

ST: Sergio Aguero – Manchester City

LONDON, ENGLAND - APRIL 23:  Sergio Aguero of Manchester City scores the opening goal past Petr Cech of Arsenal during the Emirates FA Cup Semi-Final match between Arsenal and Manchester City at Wembley Stadium on April 23, 2017 in London, England.  (Photo by Julian Finney/Getty Images,)
Aguero with a beautiful finish at Wembley

Staggeringly, there's a huge misconception surrounding Sergio Aguero this season as many consider the Argentine striker to be having a 'poor season'. Despite the forward missing seven games through suspension, facing a spell out of the team due to lack of form, he has still managed to score 27 goals in just 40 games.

In fact, Aguero has managed to score 12 goals in 12 games against City's biggest rivals this season, thus proving his status as a world class striker. On the other hand, Zlatan Ibrahimovic has scored 17 goals in 28 games, but Aguero's 17 in 26 is much more impressive.

The Argentine cannot be understated with the player also adding more to his game defensively than Ibrahimovic.

Quick Links

Edited by Staff Editor
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications