Indian Super league - Too big a dream to come true

In the world of Indian sports, there is a big tendency to blindly expect success, irrespective of the ground reality and viability of the project. After the thumping success of the IPL, the Hockey India League and Indian Badminton league were organized. These leagues did become successful to an extent, though not to the tune of IPL.

Now, from quite some time, the Indian Super league in football has gained the attention of media. Somehow, various factors were creating a doubt in the minds of fans – the projection of the grand scale of the event, the endorsements, the footfall, the coverage and participation – all seemed hyped.

No doubt football has traditional roots in India since the British rule. But still, there is a severe lack of infrastructure, resources and public interest. Additionally, even after the best attempts made by AIFF, the viewership in comparison to cricket is really far behind. Off late, the ratings of the most popular events like Durand Cup have fallen drastically. Though, with origin of players like Bhaichung Bhutia, the golden time did appear to pop up for a few years.

Let us understand why the ISL project is still doubtful. The basis for expected footfall has never appeared to be authentic – it is rather inflated. It is still not clear as to why sponsors will take interest in a project which does not seem to be financially viable. Also, it is not understood as to what positive impact the proposed super league will bring in. Additionally, many of the famous clubs are already opposing the very idea of holding a parallel league and have refused to spare their players.

The latest big blow has been that major differences have popped up between IMGR, AIFF and clubs. Media has been highlighting this, fueling further apprehensions.

With so many doubts and an unclear road map, there are chances that the proposed league will draw legal battles as well. Practically, the charm of having foreigner players in the Indian football league has failed to make it attractive, as many players of foreign origin are already playing in various clubs. Anyways, the quality of players expected for the ISL would be well below international standards. Players like Juan Mata, Luis Suarez and Ronaldo won’t come to India. Retired stars like Robbie Fowler, Hernan Crespo and David Beckham might come – but they are well past their prime. I don’t think they will draw huge crowds.

Moreover, the existing fan following of football is by and large confined to West Bengal, eastern states, Goa and Maharashtra. So, expecting a miraculous footfall in other areas is like day dreaming. Also, the way the event has been postponed so many times; it appears that everything is not running smoothly as planned.

Ultimately in this country, no game can compete with cricket and comparing it with football will never ever work. We should be focusing on investment at the grass root level rather than blindly dreaming about hi-fi leagues!