ISL vs I-League: As 2019 approaches, 5 questions that need to be answered

#4 With the big clubs missing, will the protest be successful?

Mohun Bagan and East Bengal may join ISL next year

Apart from Mohun Bagan, East Bengal and Indian Arrows, all I-League clubs are privately-owned. It was heartening to see the club joining hands together to protest against Star Sports’ decision.

But none of the big giants of Indian football joined the fray. Also, Churchill Brothers stayed out from the protest. The notable factor among this is the absence of Real Kashmir. Despite leading the protest, the club from northern part of India backed out in the last two days and was not even present in the press conference in Kolkata.

This is suspicious, given that they are one of the most affected teams in the fixture. It is not known whether they have withdrawn their support entirely or measuring the water, but Kashmir should’ve been there. The enthusiasm of the local people regarding football was setting an example for the other parts of the country, who had a bad perception about the state.

The absence of Churchill was understandable. They were relegated last season and were brought back by the AIFF as there was no representation from Western India. Staying away from the protest may be a way of paying back the courtesy.

But why were the Kolkata giants are silent? They are still very much part of the league and have a large fan following. Many of their supporters are vocal on the social media supporting the protest. However, both the clubs have denied receiving any invitation. Rumours are doing round that both the clubs will shift to the ISL next year. The indication is clear and loud.

There comes a question. Without the biggies, does the protest make any sense? The answer may be 'Yes'.

East Bengal and Mohun Bagan no more hold the bragging rights of the tournament. The I-League Private Clubs Association includes defending champions Minerva Punjab, 2016 winners Aizawl FC and current leaders Chennai City.

If the matter is reported to CAS and FIFA, then AIFF could land in deep trouble as FIFA prohibits third party interference in domestic leagues.