Sign a left back. Sign a left back. Sign a left back. Fans, analysts, and club legends have all pointed out the obvious weakness in Jurgen Klopp’s ongoing reconstruction of Liverpool’s defence. He has reinforced the heart of the defence with Matip and Klavan replacing the error-prone and haphazard Martin Skrtel. Nathaniel Clyne was Liverpool’s most consistent player for the 2015-16 season and is arguably one of the best right backs in the Premier League.
Trending
His counterpart on the left, however, is known for characteristics befitting of a young cricketer - fantastic on the front foot but susceptible when going back. Moreno’s lackluster defending simply means he’s in a similar predicament to Liverpool goalkeeper Simon Mignolet; he isn’t good enough to be first choice. The solution - Jonas Hector.
The classic left back
The FC Koln defender is a product of the German philosophy of football - technically sound, confident on the ball and capable in attack and defence. In truth, he isn’t the most flamboyant of full backs; not gifted with blistering pace or breathtaking dribbling skills (he averaged 1.0 dribble per game, most of which were out of defence). A defensive minded player, he dominates the left side of the field defensively, negating the runs of wingers and remaining solid when one on one with his opponent (he was dribbled past an average of 0.9 times per game last season).
His defensive contributions are evidence of his playing style; 6 defensive actions, 2.4 interceptions, and 2.8 tackles per game at a success rate of 68% are statistics that display his eagerness and efficiency when regaining possession and averting attacking spells. The German would offer the solidity at the back that would reduce the uncertainties of going forward while offering Liverpool alternative styles of play when required.
He is not only adept at tackling, his insight into the game allows him to break down opposition play, with an average of 2.4 interceptions per game. To top it all off, he fits Klopp’s ideology for tall defensive players. At 6 foot 1 inches, he’s taller than the average full back, an attribute he puts to good use (he wins 2.6 aerial duels on average, an attribute which will reduce Liverpool’s set-piece issue) whether in the area or in outfield play. He isn’t entirely defensively minded, and can contribute offensively too, often moving the ball out of defence, linking with wingers and putting in crosses from the flanks (4 assists and 1.8 key passes per game with a pass accuracy of 82%).
The Issue - Klopp’s Ideologies
With Liverpool’s defensive frailties over the past two seasons evident, an acquisition of Hector’s calibre appears to be a no-brainer. However, there are a few issues with signing the German defender.
Hector is 26, a late bloomer who developed his craft over his career, with a now fully fashioned style of play. It would effectively put Klopp’s ideals on hold; with Hector entering his prime, any young acquisitions would be 3rd choice and forced out on loan (a proposition the German manager does not seem open to).
Whether he could adapt to Jurgen’s high-intensity style is yet to be seen, though he seemed highly capable in that role for Joachim Low’s Germany team during their 2016 Euro campaign. His status as a German International does imply that he should be a first-team player, and would usurp Moreno as first choice, limiting the no. 18’s game time. This is the reason for Klopp’s pursuit of a young player in the position; someone who wouldn’t be perturbed by restricted game time behind the Spaniard.
The other issue is his asking price. An impressive string of performances at Euro 2016 saw a dramatic rise in stock, from an original £12 million to £20 million pounds. Liverpool find this evaluation on the pricey end.
It’s also probable that Joe Gomez is an option in that position when he returns from injury, with Milner poised to be the ‘defensive utility man’ for the Reds 2016-17 campaign. This spells catastrophe for the Reds, with teams looking to exploit the weakness the Reds’ left back position offers to them, Liverpool might find their campaign over before Karius returns in September.
Reasons to sign Hector - Defensive Versatility
Still, there is one aspect of the player that might make his £20 million evaluation a worthwhile one. Hector can play in defensive midfield, and with Can still developing and Lucas currently injured, Liverpool have no cover in that position. Jonas played in defensive midfield for F.C. Koln 5 times last season and looked more than capable.
He offers world class ability in two blatantly susceptible positions and could be the final fit to the Liverpool’s defence. Hector would offer a more resolute option against more formidable opponents, while Moreno would use his attacking ability against weaker teams.
Klopp has to reassess and alter his long-term plans for this transfer window. Or he may quickly find out how unforgiving English Premier League football can be.
