#1 Andriy Shevchenko (AC Milan) - 14 goals
The Ukrainian legend was an instrumental part of the stellar Milan squad of the early 21st century and widely touted to be one of the best to have worn the prestigious red and black stripes.
Of the many title-deciding kicks, his most memorable one for the club was arguably the winning penalty in Old Trafford that clinched AC Milan its fourth European cup in 2003 against Juventus.
However, he's popped up with similarly crucial strikes in the Milan derby when the teams once contested for the Scudetto and Inter Milan was one of his favourite victims with 14 goals against them in all competitions, the highest in the Milan derby.
Shevchenko normally saved his best for matches like these, thriving in the hostile atmosphere that used to build up whenever the sides met. His goal that knocked Inter Milan out in the semi-finals of 2003 Champions League aptly testifies to the same.