PSG
Gianluigi Donnarumma - 4.5/10
The Italy international made a number of routine saves in the first half. However, his moment of madness in the 60th minute set the chain of events in motion for PSG's elimination.
Nuno Mendes - 6/10
Mendes combined well with Mbappe in the first half to put PSG in the ascendancy but his influence in the game waned after the break.
Presnel Kimpembe - 5/10
The France international was one of the first PSG players to lose his cool when they went behind. He made a number of rash challenges and was shown a yellow card in the 83rd minute. However, Kimpembe also managed five clearances and two blocks.
Marquinhos - 5/10
Marquinhos' mishit clearance put the ball on a plate for Benzema to score his hat-trick. He also failed to inspire PSG with his leadership as his teammates lost the plot in the second half.
Achraf Hakimi - 5.5/10
Vinicius Junior's attacking output limited Hakimi's usual attacking contributions. He was the busiest PSG defender before making way for Julian Draxler with three minutes to go.
Leandro Paredes - 5.5/10
Paredes was shown an early booking and had a pass accuracy of 91.9% before being replaced by Idrissa Gueye in the 71st minute.
Marco Veratti - 5.5/10
Veratti was far from his best against Real Madrid and was guilty of giving the ball away on a number of occasions to put his side under pressure.
Danilo - 5/10
The Portugal midfielder was not very effective in his role in shielding the defense and was replaced by Angel di Maria as his side pushed for a second goal.
Kylian Mbappe - 8/10
Mbappe is the only PSG player to emerge from both games with any credit. He passed his audition in front of the Real Madrid faithful with flying colors and was let down by his lethargic teammates. The Frenchman put the ball in the net on three occasions but saw two goals chalked off due to offside.
Lionel Messi - 5.5/10
The seven-time Ballon d'Or winner dropped deep to try and influence proceedings but was largely ineffectual. Messi rarely had a sight of goal and a late freekick that sailed narrowly over the bar was his most telling contribution in the game.
Neymar Jr. - 6/10
Neymar provided the assist for PSG's only goal of the night but other than that, the world's most expensive player failed to sparkle when it mattered most.
Substitutes
Idrissa Gueye - 5.5/10
The Senegal international replaced Leandro Paredes in the 71st minute and made one interception in the time he spent on the field.
Angel di Maria - 5/10
Di Maria was a late addition to the game but did not make too much of an impact.
Julian Draxler - N/A
The former Schalke 04 man came on with three minutes to go and barely had a touch of the ball.