Robin and the Wayne! So is Sir Alex, Alfred the Butler now?
After the long awaited transfer saga, Robin turns a RED DEVIL. A stunning buy indeed, good signing. Maybe he’s entering his peak now. Being in the right place at the right time is a very underrated skill. That’s why RVP scored a lot last season, he has the knack. I don’t think we have had a ‘scary’ strikeforce in 3 years after the Rooney, Berba, Tevez, Ronaldo era. Van Persie would certainly help to change that. If you compare what we had last year to City’s four options, it’s no wonder they won on goal difference.
71 goals between Rooney and Van Persie last season. Sounds good to me. RVP is definitely a more out and out striker, getting most of his goals from inside the box. Rooney on the other hand, drops a lot deeper – without his penalties he would have scored 26 goals, meaning about 1 in 5 of his others came from outside the box (excluding free kicks). On this evidence, you could see them striking up a good partnership if Van Persie joins in with immediate effect, with Rooney playing off RVP. They wouldn’t really get in each other’s way, from the looks of things.
Strengths
Experience
Wayne is a more clinical finisher and has better movement in the box than RVP, but RVP is better technically and links play better and is more creative. Reverse the roles they played last season and you’d see the best of them in a altogether different opinion. Just contrasting this, it was evidently seen that Van Persie’s goals often came from a pass to him from out wide or in midfield, and he would take a touch and finish it. The majority of Rooney’s goals came after he had played the ball off to somebody, and he sprinted into the box to get a header, or rebound off the keeper. Which would indicate that RVP is better further forward. Of course, if both played together they would quickly work it out for themselves.
Competition for places
Formation Options
With the addition of ammunition or rather re-enforced Arsenal, United can employ traditional 4-4-2, 4-4-1-1 or 4-3-1-2 or even 4-2-3-1.
My opinion would be a 4-2-3-1 with Kagawa playing CAM along with Rooney, Rvp, Valencia/Nani completing the front 4. I would prefer playing Rooney out wide because Kagawa is not as good as Rooney defensively so he would leave too much space for Evra to be attacked from, hence why he shouldn’t play there. And RVP, Rooney and Kagawa would probably interchange a bit. Our left wingers have to track back and Kagawa is not too good at that.
Support from Kagawa’s footballing abilities
Weaknesses
Aerial ability
Van Persie has very poor timing with headers and Rooney seems to be a lot better with his head than RVP. Competiting consistently on the aerial basis with taller defenders would be a challenge worth watching.
Injuries
Everyone knows the long list of injuries and the long spells on the treatment table. Maybe, its an age when footballers peak. Remember Teddy Sheringham ?
RVP’s alledged reason to leave was the club’s lack of ambition, they at least appear to be showing some for the 1st time in a while, maybe it’s too little too late for RVP?