"Very exciting event": Pokemon GO Reddit sarcastic about Hatch Day

Pokemon GO’s latest Hatch Day event has sparked a wave of sarcasm on Reddit, with many players expressing frustration over its structure and rewards. Reddit user u/Foulmouth232 kicked off the discussion with a post accompanied by a meme capturing the lukewarm reception. Reddit user u/Foulmouth232 stated:

"Very exciting event"

Very exciting event 🥱 byu/Foulmouth232 inpokemongo

While the idea of a Hatch Day initially intrigued some, the details revealed a lackluster experience: no Community Day moves for evolved Pokemon, a narrow three-hour window (2 PM to 5 PM), a paid Stardust bonus ticket, and overpriced Ultra Hatch boxes costing $19.99. To top it off, the wild spawns were Mankey and similar common species, leaving players underwhelmed.

The sarcastic undertone of u/Foulmouth232’s post resonated widely with the community, prompting a range of reactions. From critiques of Niantic’s event planning to begrudging praise for certain aspects, the discussion highlighted both player dissatisfaction and faint optimism.

Reddit user u/NazcaanKing’s comment encapsulated a common grievance among players,

"I just wish the single Johto pokemon I needed wasn't available one time in 6 months for 3 hours while I'm at work. But that's Niantic in a nutshell"

The frustration of missing out due to work or other commitments is a recurring theme in Niantic’s event planning, leading many to feel alienated.

u/FamineArcher shared a quirky workaround for maximizing distance during Hatch events — using a drawstring bag to swing the phone while multitasking.

Comment byu/Foulmouth232 from discussion inpokemongo

This creative solution reflects the lengths some players go to in order to make the most of limited opportunities.

u/Superawesomeflyguy brought a rare note of excitement, highlighting their enthusiasm for hatching Magby during the event. For players like them, who have specific goals like obtaining XL Candy for Magmortar, the event offers some value.

"Haven’t seen a magmar in what seems like eons and magmortar is the next perfect pokemon on my list to max out and he’s been in limbo until I can get some CXL. So I’m a bit excited about the magby hatches"

This underscores how personal objectives can influence perceptions of event quality.

Meanwhile, u/cheeriodust’s comment offered a balanced perspective. They acknowledged the event’s shortcomings but appreciated the half-hatch distance and free-to-play accessibility for those who prepare ahead.

Comment byu/Foulmouth232 from discussion inpokemongo

They also contrasted the Hatch Day favorably with longer ticketed events, emphasizing that the brevity of the Hatch event makes it easy to skip if uninterested.

---

The Pokemon GO Hatch Day conundrum: Balancing accessibility and engagement

Casual players are finding it difficult to adjust with the game's current state (Image via The Pokemon Company)

The Hatch Day event serves as a microcosm of broader issues in Pokemon GO’s event design. While the three-hour window and paid bonuses alienate many players, others find niche value in the event’s limited scope. For those chasing specific goals, like shiny baby Pokemon or XL Candy, Hatch Day offers a fleeting opportunity.

However, the heavy emphasis on monetization — through paid tickets and premium boxes — continues to draw criticism from the community.

Niantic’s tendency to lock meaningful content behind paywalls or rigid schedules remains a sore point. Players frequently lament the lack of flexibility in events, which disproportionately favors those with ample free time and disposable income. Yet, for all its faults, Hatch Day at least avoids locking core bonuses behind paywalls, offering some accessibility for free-to-play participants.

Pokemon GO’s Hatch Day event has proven to be another polarizing chapter in the game’s ongoing evolution. While some players find ways to extract enjoyment or value, many remain disillusioned by the recurring patterns of monetization and limited accessibility.

As Reddit’s sarcastic tone suggests, Niantic’s event design could benefit from a closer alignment with player expectations and needs. Whether Hatch Day becomes a fleeting memory or a signpost for change will depend on how feedback shapes future events.

---

Check out our other Pokemon GO guides:

• Ditto disguises
• Buddy Evolution Adventure Together guide
• Best Fast Attacks in the game
• Sierra counters
• Cliff counters
• Arlo counters
• Giovanni counters
• Team GO Rocket Grunts
• Pokemon Go Evolution Calculator
• Pokemon Type Calculator