Has Ms. Marvel been a major disaster in the MCU? Explained

Ms. Marvel: A Controversial Turn in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (Image via Marvel Studios)
Ms. Marvel: A Controversial Turn in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (Image via Marvel Studios)

The Marvel Cinematic Universe has consistently showcased a tapestry of diverse characters and compelling narratives that have enchanted global audiences. One of its offerings, Ms. Marvel, offers a deep dive into the world of Kamala Khan, a 16-year-old Pakistani-American from Jersey City.

By juxtaposing the nuances of teenage life with a poignant exploration of Muslim-American experiences, the series aimed to merge cultural depth with superhero escapades. However, for many MCU aficionados, Ms. Marvel didn't quite deliver on its lofty promises.

Instead of seamlessly integrating Kamala's journey with the grand tapestry of the MCU, the series often felt disjointed. The anticipation of exploring a new character's evolution was met with narrative incoherence and thematic misdirection, making it a standout in the MCU lineup, but not necessarily for the right reasons.

The challenges faced by the show are manifold. From an abrupt change in Kamala's powers to a plot oscillating between grounded reality and chaotic fantasy, Ms. Marvel struggled to find its narrative footing. As viewers dive deeper into the series, these challenges become even more evident, raising questions about the direction and vision behind one of MCU's most anticipated series.


Ms. Marvel: A journey from relatability to complexity

1) A grounded start with a heroic twist

Kamala Khan's tale captivates with its authentic, down-to-earth perspective. Central to Ms. Marvel is the journey of a young person uncovering unique powers amidst the trials of adolescence. The story resonates deeply, portraying growth and identity challenges, especially from the lens of a post-9/11 Muslim-American experience.

The first two episodes promise a Nickelodeon-esque charm, portraying Kamala's school life, her close bond with Bruno, and a Scott Pilgrim-style of storytelling. The celebration of Pakistani culture is noteworthy, providing a refreshing, diverse perspective often lacking in mainstream media.

Additionally, the positive depiction of Muslims stands out, although certain historical narratives, like the partitioning of India and Pakistan, are arguably simplified for the series.


2) Navigating a complex narrative

As the series progresses, its tonal and narrative coherence seems to waver. It grapples with a muddled plot and underdeveloped characters by attempting to integrate Kamala's small-town story into the broader MCU.

The change in Kamala's powers is one point of contention among fans. While changes from comic book to screen adaptations are not uncommon, this shift made Kamala's abilities resemble that of DC's Green Lantern, leaving some fans disappointed.

The introduction of characters like Kamran, Najma, and the DODC, combined with the perplexing dimensions of Noor, leave many viewers scratching their heads. Why not stick to the comic's origin story, which provided a cleaner, more cohesive narrative?

The series also struggles with pacing. Over six episodes, viewers watch Kamala juggle three potential love interests, witness essential characters like Bruno get sidelined, and see important plot points hastily introduced and discarded.


3) Disneyfied or just different?

The tone and style of Ms. Marvel stand in contrast to other MCU offerings. It resonates more with a Disney Channel vibe than a typical MCU miniseries, seemingly aimed at a younger audience. While diversifying audiences is commendable, it appears to have impacted the narrative's richness.


Conclusion

Ms. Marvel stands as a pivotal stride for diversity in the MCU. The show truly sparkles when diving into Kamala's personal growth, her bonds, and her rich cultural heritage. Yet, weaving her story into the expansive MCU tapestry results in a narrative that sometimes seems congested and unfulfilling.

The overarching sentiment remains mixed. Some applaud its boldness and representation, while others lament its missed potential. As Kamala Khan prepares to make her way into the next MCU movie, The Marvels, one can only hope her character finds the depth and narrative cohesion that was amiss in her standalone series.

Quick Links

Edited by Upasya Bhowal
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications