#4 Gene Snitsky
Despite limited mobility, poor technical skills, and non existent charisma WWE tried like mad to get Gene Snitsky over.
He was booked into a high profile feud with Kane and Lita almost out of the gate, which contained a very distasteful angle involving a miscarriage. Snitsky's 'it's not my fault' catchphrase didn't do anything to get him over, either.
Finally, Vince McMahon decided that since Snitsky was unpleasant looking they would shave his body hair and display his misshapen form for all the world to see. Unfortunately, he still had no skills or charisma, and he eventually faded away.
Edited by Ben Roberts