WWE Rumor Mill: Dave Meltzer claims that the Rock winning The Royal Rumble and facing Reigns at WrestleMania was not true at all

What the story?

Last Saturday, WrestleVotes - a reliable source who has broken wrestling stories such as Neville’s WWE departure, WWE switching to dual branded pay-per-views beginning at Backlash, and Bobby Lashley replacing John Cena in the World Cup tournament – released a rumor on the original plans for The Royal Rumble, which saw The Rock returning to win the annual event and challenging Roman Reigns for the Universal championship at WrestleMania 35 prior to Roman Reigns’ leukemia diagnosis.

However, according to Dave Meltzer of The Wrestling Observer Newsletter, the claim that the WrestleVotes account has put out was false.

In Case You Didn’t Know…

On September 29th, the WrestleVotes account revealed that a repeat winner was penciled in to win The Royal Rumble in 2019.

Let’s just say as of now, it’s a repeat winner.

— WrestleVotes (@WrestleVotes) September 29, 2018

Many fans and media speculated on who could possibly be the 2019 RR winner, with the Rock heavily rumored to return to WWE in January and win the annual event.

News broke that Rock was actually a betting favorite to win the rumble back in August, with Daniel Bryan and Seth Rollins a close second and third.

The reasoning behind The Rock winning the rumble was meant to put over Roman Reigns, solidifying his status as a main eventer. However, Reigns shocked the world in late October by relinquishing the Universal championship due to a battle with leukemia.

With Reigns out indefinitely, the plans for the former WWE Universal champion was immediately scrapped due to the heartbreaking news. On December 8th, the WrestleVotes account revealed that at one point, the plan was for The Rock to win the Royal Rumble and challenge Reigns for the title at WrestleMania 35.

Rumble tidbit: Plan at one point was for The Rock to win the Royal Rumble & face Roman Reigns at Mania. That’s obviously not happening. Can Rock still win it & face Lesnar? I guess. Depends what kind of agreement Rock and WWE have. Once plans changed, Rock may have reconsidered.

— WrestleVotes (@WrestleVotes) December 8, 2018

The heart of the matter

However, it appears that might’ve not been the case after all. Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter refuted the claim, with Wrestletalk posting his statement from the F4W message board noting, “This didn’t sound believable, but I checked. Not true at all”

WrestleVotes responded to Meltzer, noting that plans always change in WWE or in wrestling in general and stood by his original post on Rock winning the Rumble in 2019:

Seems like @davemeltzerWON is refuting my tweet about Rock & the Rumble. That’s fair. But in wrestling, plans change ALL the time. To say a trusted source didn’t give me this information is dumb. As everyone can tell, my sources are usually pretty good. So I believe them. Still.

— WrestleVotes (@WrestleVotes) December 12, 2018

What’s Next?

There hasn’t been much speculation in regards to who could possibly win the rumble next year since plans clearly had to change. However, according to a recent report at Wrestling Newsletter Observer, Seth Rollins vs. Brock Lesnar is currently penciled in for WrestleMania 35. Whether that means he’ll win the rumble or not remains unclear, but that could be a huge indication of the 2019 RR winner.