Madden's ratings draw immense attention, boiling players down to numbers. The controversial 99 overall club is hard to maintain, seeing frequent turnover as new faces join yearly.
Kupp missed breaking the record for receiving yards in a season by 18 yards. Injuries impacted his 2022 performance, but with a healthy QB, he has a good chance of replicating his 2021 success in 2023.
If that happens, EA might be compelled to elevate Kupp to the top tier in virtual football. In Madden 24, he achieved 812 yards & 6 TDs, earning a 96 overall rating.
Surprisingly, the WR has never been in Madden's 99 club, despite receiving 99 overall cards in Ultimate Team mode. His simulation football rating never reached the highest accolade.
He ranked second in receiving yards last season, just behind Jefferson. If Hill repeats that performance, EA may face backlash for not including him in the 99 club.
Watt has never achieved a 99 overall rating. Despite rumors, he received a 96 overall rating instead of the anticipated 99 last year, as reported by SI.
In 2022, injuries hindered the pass rusher's performance. If he regains form and approaches his near-record 22.5 sacks, a 99 club status is probable.