On Wednesday, September 11, the 2024 VMAs were rolled and Billboard released a ranking of the event's best performers, with BLACKPINK's LISA seated at the last position. The 2024 MTV VMAs, otherwise known as the Video Music Awards, is an event that gathered several music artists from around the world such as Sabrina Carpenter, Chappell Roan, etc.
The 2024 MVAs, hosted by rapper Megan Thee Stallion, celebrated the best music videos of the year. The event featured performances from various artists, which were ranked by Billboard.
This is what their list read:
- Sabrina Carpenter
- Chappell Roan
- Karol G
- Katy Perry
- Rauw Alejandro
- Benson Boone
- LL COOL J
- Megan Thee Stallion
- Halsey
- Lenny Kravitz
- Shawn Mendes
- Eminem
- GloRilla
- Camila Cabello
- Anitta
- Lisa
BLACKPINK's Lisa received mixed reactions for her performance at the 2024 VMAs, which was ranked last. Some netizens felt she was lip-syncing rather than performing live, which they believed led to the low ranking. While some agreed with the ranking, arguing it was unfair compared to other live performances, Lisa’s fans defended her, insisting her performance did not deserve to be ranked last.
Here are a few reactions to the ongoing divide on Billboard's ranking:
"Lisa getting whacked for lip syncing and bad performing by non-fans, locals and billboard and other outlets omfg….it’s bad," wrote a netizen.
"I really liked new woman & was excited for the performance but it was 80% lipsync and the choreography was mostly just her moving her hands and hair. And it felt like she focused more on the camera than the crowd" said a fan.
"last place cause she lip synced all the way through. Why even attend a award show if u aren’t gonna perform live sing live" stated a netizen on X.
"they put LaLisman in last place because all she did was lip sync and no one was having it" added another netizen.
Fans, on the other hand, expressed that BLACKPINK's LISA's performance deserved a better ranking.
"Lisa in last place just lets me know to not take anything billboard says seriously. Camila should be way higher too her performance was iconic," said a fan on X.
"Lisa at last but why?" added another fan.
"LISA AT LAST??? Baby no her performance was Top 5," commented an X user.
"Meanwhile Lisa was one of the best performers," added another fan.
Additionally, the New York Post also released an article ranking the 2024 VMA performance from the best to worst, with BLACKPINK's LISA's performance sitting on the list of worst performances.
All you need to know about BLACKPINK's LISA's performance at the 2024 MTV VMAs
On September 11, the 2024 MTV VMAs were rolled out at the UBS Arena in Elmont, New York. BLACKPINK's LISA was seated as one of the performers at the event, and the other performers included Sabrina Carpenter, Camila Cabello, Katy Perry, Meghan Thee Stallion, etc.
The idol performed her two latest tracks, New Woman ft. Rosalía and Rockstar. While fans enjoyed the performance and clips from the same soon began to dominate the internet, an online debate kickstarted alongside. Many accused the idol of lip-synching throughout her performance and people argued that it wasn't the right move at an honorable award show like the MTV VMAs.
However, fans also clapped back saying that it didn't seem like BLACKPINK's LISA lip-synced. Alongside the debate between netizens, Billboard's release of the performance rankings at the 2024 MTV VMAs further fueled the debate. Since BLACKPINK's LISA was ranked last, netizens pushed the fact that it was because of the lip-sync.
Here's what Billboard said about her performance:
"The BLACKPINK member has proven herself adept at killer choreography and eye-popping visuals in the past, bt LISA's solo turn at the 2024 VMAs felt like a swing and a miss. "New Woman" could have used a little oomph from Rosalía, and the "Rockstar" choreography was solid but never head-turning, much less show-stopping."
After Billboard's ranking and commentary on BLACKPINK's LISA's 2024 VMAs performance landed on the internet, the online debate on the idol's stage has increased in intensity.