“This is not even THEIR best song”- Internet divided over Pitchfork ranking NewJeans’ ‘Super Shy’ as the best K-Pop song of the 2020s so far

On October 1, 2024, Pitchfork, an online music publication, unveiled its list of the 'Top 100 Songs of the 2020s' so far. K-pop girl group NewJeans secured the 13th spot on the list with their hit song Super Shy from the 2023 EP Get Up.

This recognition made them the only K-pop act on the list, leading to mixed reactions online. Many fans celebrated NewJeans’ impressive achievement, congratulating the group for receiving international recognition, while others expressed disagreement.

Some fans argued that Super Shy isn’t even the group’s best work, suggesting that more popular tracks like Ditto or Hype Boy might have been more deserving of the honor. A user on X, @hauntedbai wrote,

"its not even THEIR best song."

"well they’re wrong because ditto hype boy supernatural and how sweet superior," a fan commented.

"i feel like pitchfork needs to do better with their analyses of kpop songs because this isnt even newjeans best song," another user wrote on X.

"newjeans has better songs in their own discography like ditto literally exists," an X user mentioned.

"ill never understand this hype sigh. all their other songs are better PLEAAAASE what about queen ditto," a fan remarked.

The debate continued online, reflecting divided opinions on the group's diverse discography, while fans congratulate the group on this milestone.

"Got the world in a chokehold. No useless remixes and collabs needed. Just good music and talented artists. NewJeans is always gonna be THAT GROUP," a fan commented.

"Literally one of the biggest hits to ever come from kpop… Super Shy you will always be famous," an X user wrote.

"deserved & was mega viral around the entire fcking globe," a fan mentioned.

---

"NewJeans feel revelatory in their decorum"- Pitchfork lists the K-pop group's Super Shy as the 13th best song of the 2020's so far

Pitchfork recently released a list of the 'Top 100 Songs of the 2020s' so far, with NewJeans' track Super Shy landing at number 13. The publication praised the K-pop group for blending genres in a subtle yet impactful way.

According to Pitchfork, the K-pop track stands out for its understated charm, with its mix of drum 'n' bass and Jersey club production providing a relaxed, dreamy atmosphere.

The song’s theme of youthful possibility resonated with listeners. The publication stated:

"K-pop has always been home to audacious genre-blending, but NewJeans feel revelatory in their decorum, draping their dance music in hushed atmospheres. “Super Shy” is their most effortless masterstroke: The drum ’n’ bass and Jersey club production doesn’t pop so much as drift, providing a breezy foundation for a wistful hook."

Here are top 15 songs from Pitchfork’s list:

1. Lana Del Rey: “A&W” (2023)
2. RXK Nephew: “American tterroristt” (2020)
3. Kendrick Lamar: “Not Like Us” (2024)
4. Caroline Polachek: “Bunny Is a Rider” (2021)
5. Low: “Days Like These” (2021)
6. ANOHNI and the Johnsons: “It Must Change” (2023)
7. Alex G: “Runner” (2022)
8. Bob Dylan: “Murder Most Foul” (2020)
9. Fiona Apple: “I Want You to Love Me” (2020)
10. Bfb Da Packman: “Free Joe Exotic” [ft. Sada Baby] (2020)
11. Cassandra Jenkins: “Hard Drive” (2021)
12. NewJeans: “Super Shy” (2023)
13. Wednesday: “Chosen to Deserve” (2023)
14. Alvvays: “Belinda Says” (2022)
15. Jazmine Sullivan: “Pick Up Your Feelings” (2020)

---

The five-member group is currently at the center of attention as rumors circulate online about the group potentially leaving ADOR, sparked by reports of internal conflicts within the company.

While speculation grows, no official statement has been released to confirm or deny the situation.