What is a mistrial? Young Thug's YSL RICO case faces potential risk

Young Thug’s RICO case has landed in a risky situation after a new witness, rapper Slimelife Shawty AKA Wunnie Lee took the stand and reached a plea agreement in exchange for his testimony.

As per 11 Alive, the rapper has been one of the many co-defendants in the indictment, who was now asked to identify others involved in the case by reviewing social media posts.

While reading a caption from one of the posts, Lee mistakenly read the unredacted version from a paper exhibit instead of the redacted one shown on a monitor. The unredacted version included the hashtag #FreeQua, which Lee accidentally read aloud to the jury.

Since the jury in the Young Thug case wasn't supposed to know which defendants had been incarcerated, the defence teams immediately requested a mistrial.

Furthermore, as Bruce Harvey, the attorney for Quardavious Nichols spoke up and stated how the “state is not prepping their witnesses,” the judge in the case, Paige Whitaker slammed the prosecution, as she said:

"What I'm trying to do is fix your sloppiness so everyone would not have wasted 12 months of their lives in this trial.”

Hot New Hip Hop also reported that due to this and the many past incidents taken place in the court, Judge Paige Reese Whitaker is now allegedly considering declaring a mistrial yet again. For the unversed, a mistrial is a trial that has not reached a conclusion, as it has been either declared invalid or has paused in the middle.

---

“Would you like a mistrial without evidence?”: Meaning of a mistrial explored as Judge Whitaker slams the prosecutors in the Young Thug RICO case

As Young Thug’s RICO case reaches a potential mistrial, several clips also started floating on social media from the court hearing held on Wednesday, October 23, 2024. In a few clips, Judge Whitaker can be heard talking about a potential mistrial as she says:

"I am sorry y'all have this gigantic, ginormous, universe of evidence that, maybe if you narrowed down, you wouldn't be making these kinds of mistakes. But, I believe that to be a mistake. So, I'm gonna deny a motion for a mistrial with prejudice… would you like a mistrial without evidence?"

As per USA Today, mistrials are declared when a jury is not able to reach a verdict even after numerous attempts. It can also take place if the judge in the case suspects a procedural error or misconduct. Britannica also mentions that if a mistrial takes place, the trial is terminated, however, it can be renewed if the attorneys file for a retrial with a new jury.

Furthermore, it is also worth noting that while Judge Paige Reese Whitaker has allegedly considered a mistrial now, she denied the possibility of one back in July, this year, as she stated that the motion asks her to act as an “appellate court.”

At the time, she also denied the request for any bond for Young Thug, and made it clear that she will not “reconsider any bonds or change in circumstances.”

The trial of Young Thug, the rapper born Jeffery Williams, has officially become the longest-running criminal trial in Georgia’s history. It began in January 2023 and has stretched on for nearly two years with jury selection alone taking months due to the complexity of the case and the extensive number of defendants.

The case centres on allegations that Young Thug is the leader of the Atlanta-based gang YSL, which prosecutors claim is involved in organized criminal activity, including murder, armed robbery, and drug trafficking. However, Thug and his legal team have denied all allegations and maintained that YSL is merely a music collective.