"Could've stayed missing" — Fans react to Dave and Vanessa's appearance on The Ultimatum reunion

Netflix's The Ultimatum explores relationships through ultimatums and trial marriages. Season 3 featured a mix of decisions, breakups, and reconciliations, culminating in a reunion episode on December 18, 2024. Dave and Vanessa, who left the show in episode 4 during the trial marriage phase, returned for the reunion, sparking fan reactions and questions about their inclusion.

Dave and Vanessa shared their perspectives on their experience in the show while the rest of the cast revisited their decisions and outcomes post-show. The reunion provided updates on relationships, clarified conflicts, and revealed new details, offering closure for some participants while introducing fresh tensions for others.

Fans of the show The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On, took to X sharing their opinions on Dave and Vanessa's appearance in the reunion episode.

"Dave and Vanessa could’ve stayed missing. Because truly who invited them to this reunion and what is she even saying?!? #TheUltimatum" - one fan commented.

Why are Vanessa and Dave even here?? Like if you “didn’t need the experiment,” or feel like you “don’t owe your cast mates anything,” then why are we wasting a segment? The way she’s talking to Nick is so…" #theultimatumReunion #TheUltimatium - another user wrote.

"Dave and Vanessa could have done this from a television screen... #TheUltimatum" - a fan tweeted.

"Vanessa and Dave are wack. They shouldn’t have been invited to the reunion. F**k everyone that left rudely. #TheUltimatum" - a tweet read.

Some fans criticized the couple for claiming they "won" by leaving The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On midway through the show.

"I like how no one brought up the fact that Dave was probably happy that Vanessa wanted to leave because he realized that he wasn’t the hot commodity he thought he was going into this. #TheUltimatum #TheUltimatumS3 #theultimatumReunion" - another user commented.

"Vanessa really thinks she won with Dave #TheUltimatum" - a netizen tweeted.

"Dave & Vanessa could’ve stayed home #TheUltimatum #TheUltimatumReunion" - a fan said.

"Vanessa and Dave… they didn’t even need to come #TheUltimatum" - one tweet said.

---

Dave and Vanessa address their exit in the reunion of The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On

Dave and Vanessa left the experiment early, citing challenges during the trial marriage phase. Vanessa explained,

“Once we moved in, it felt like a light switch went off,” referring to her time with Nick.

She addressed her early exit, explaining how the trial marriage with Nick became unbearable due to his alleged rude behavior and heavy drinking. Aside from their segment, the reunion highlighted unresolved issues among the cast. Zaina presented evidence to dispute earlier claims made by J.R., bringing a chip embedded in her nail that contained saved messages.

During this exchange, Zaina stated, “I brought this to clear things up because there’s been a lot of misinformation.”

The Ultimatum reunion also featured updates on Mariah and Caleb, who announced they were still engaged and planning a destination wedding. However, a confrontation with Aria, Caleb’s trial partner, brought tension. Aria claimed, “You send mixed signals,” referencing Caleb’s social media activity. Mariah responded directly, asking Caleb, “What’s going on?”

The episode concluded with a reflective moment as Aria and Scotty discussed their breakup. Scotty stated, “I’ll always be there for her,” while Aria opened up about personal challenges after the show.

---

The reunion episode of The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On is currently streaming on Netflix.