"He's gorgeous, but very young" — Love Island: All Stars' India Reynolds reveals secret crush on Luca Bish

India Reynolds (Image source via Instagram @lovefromreyn)
India Reynolds (Image source via Instagram @lovefromreyn)

India Reynolds, known for her appearance in Love Island season 5, made a return to the villa in Love Island: All Stars 2025. Unfortunately, her journey was short-lived as she became the first contestant to leave the villa. After her exit, India revealed her secret crush on fellow contestant Luca Bish, a fisherman from Love Island season 11.

During an interview with The Sun on January 26, 2025, India shared,

“I think if Luca was a bit older, then maybe Luca. I did think he was really funny. He's gorgeous, but he is very young.”

India explained that her attraction was because of Luca’s humor and personality, though the age gap was a factor. The confession came a week after her elimination from the villa, as she reflected on her time in South Africa.


India reflects on her time in the villa of Love Island: All Stars

India Reynolds’ Love Island: All Stars journey ended early after she was left without a partner. Tina Stinnes, another returning contestant, entered the villa and expressed her interest in Scott Thomas, leading to India’s elimination. Reflecting on her experience, India shared that the outcome did not surprise her.

Speaking about the situation, India said,

“As soon as Tina came in, she said she liked Scott. So I thought, I'm either going to be single or I'm going to be leaving.”

She explained that she observed Scott’s growing interest in Tina, which made her realise that her time in the villa was likely coming to an end. India mentioned that Scott’s behaviour made her feel that he might have developed an interest in Tina, which confirmed her expectations about the outcome. Despite the early exit, India appreciated the opportunity to return to the villa and reconnect with familiar faces.

Looking back, India remarked that staying in the villa might have given her and Scott a chance to overcome the situation, but it was clear to her that the dynamics had shifted.

“If I’d have stayed in, we probably would have got over it, but I wasn’t feeling that good about the situation,” she said.

India’s departure occurred after Tina Stinnes coupled up with Scott Thomas, leaving her single.


Luca Bish’s time in the Love Island: All Stars villa

Luca Bish, a contestant on Love Island: All Stars, was coupled with Grace Jackson from season 11. Reflecting on her time in the villa, India Reynolds shared her thoughts on Luca, admitting that she found him attractive but noted their age difference as a significant factor.

At 24 years old, Luca was one of the younger contestants in a villa with a wide age gap with the other contestants, which seemed to influence his experience according to India.

India explained,

“I think Luca was struggling because obviously last time he went in, everyone was a similar age to him, so this time maybe it was a little bit harder for him.”

She felt that the age differences among the contestants presented new challenges for him compared to his previous season of Love Island.

While they did not explore a romantic connection, India revealed that Luca left a positive impression on her. She appreciated his humor and personality, even though their paths in the villa didn’t align.


New episodes of Love Island: All Stars air exclusively on ITV2 and ITVX every week from Monday to Sunday with Saturdays as exception.

Quick Links

Edited by Sezal Srivastava
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications