The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City season 5 aired its season finale this week on January 15, 2025. The segment saw the cast wrap up the latest season with an eventful dinner, as several arguments ensued. However, there was one that was unexpected.
As Angie Katsanevas asked Mary Cosby if she wanted a slice of pizza, the latter rolled her eyes but didn't respond. It prompted Angie to ask why she was being "quiet" with her, and the cast member said Angie had run after Britani after she accused her of recording the cast.
Fans of the reality show commented on the segment and were critical of Mary's behavior towards Angie.
"Oh come on, Mary. I think getting upset with Angie because she spoke to Britani is a little much.," one person wrote on X.
"I have empathy for Mary and I love that she’s opening up to the girls but Angie is owed an apology. Angie didn’t abandon her and she shouldn’t shoulder this reaction from Mary. Like no! I love Mary but this is a no for me," a fan commented.
"Quiet as it’s kept, Mary’s reaction to Angie in this moment is the same behavior we criticize Lisa for. Like this isn’t how to be a friend. Loyalty doesn’t mean I do whatever you want and only support you. No ma’am. I’m not feeling this. Angie STOP apologizing," a tweet read.
Fans of The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City season 5 commented on Mary and Angie's emotional conversation following their spat.
"Now wait a minute! Mary better give this raw emotion! I appreciate her self-awareness in this moment to recognize what was truly fueling her lashing out. And shout out to Angie for understanding Mary and receiving her feelings. Angie is a true friend to Mary," a person wrote.
"That was at first so upsetting, then so gratifying- I watch these shows expecting shallowness and stupidity, humor at best. Seeing such realness just took me so aback- God bless Mary and Angie," a fan commented.
"Angie to Mary - “You’ve changed my life” Mary’s face once Angie said that showed Mary deep down LOVES Angie and this is a friendship that’s not worth losing," a tweet read.
Fans of The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City season 5 further said:
"Angie saying Mary changed her life I could cry," a person wrote.
"Mary holding Britani’s feet to the fire & clocking Angie for running after her after they just got into it is real af & why I will ALWAYS love her," a fan commented.
"I love you"— Angie apologizes to Mary in The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City season 5 finale
In the season finale of The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City season 5, Mary and Angie got into an argument over dinner. When Angie asked what had happened, Mary explained she was upset by the cast member's behavior when she went to comfort Britani in the previous episode.
Mary said the RHOSLC star didn't care about Mary and that she ran after her. Angie got emotional and told Mary she had spent months trying to gain her confidence while the latter said she hadn't asked her to do that.
"That was a choice you made," she told Angie.
The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City season 5 star Angie told Mary she had chosen to be her friend and recalled the reality star saying God brought them together. She added that they both believed that, and Mary said she did believe that.
Mary said she was "big on loyalty" and Angie asked her to look at her as she apologized for hurting her. The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City cast member asked Mary to give her, her hand but the cast member refused and said she was "not playing" with Angie.
"I love you," Angie said.
The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City season 5 star further told Mary she had changed her life as she started crying. As both cast members sobbed, Angie told Mary she saw her differently than everyone else and told her she didn't like that she was "shutting" Angie out.
Fans of The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City City season 5 commented on their exchange online and criticized Mary for confronting Angie.
Episodes of The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City season 5 are available to stream on Bravo.