"Elma you are so finished" — Love Island: All Stars fans react to Ronnie rating Harriett's kiss a 10

Love Island: All Stars season 2 aired a new episode on Thursday, January 23, 2025. It saw Harriett enter the villa as the show's latest "bombshell" (newcomer) and stir relationship dynamics. She not only reunited with her ex-partner Ronnie, but also scored a 10 after kissing him during a challenge where he was blindfolded.

Ronnie claimed he knew it was Harriett due to their history.

"I know that kiss. 10," he said.

While the remaining islanders watched the scene in disbelief, Ronnie's present partner, Elma, was displeased. While speaking to the cameras, she expressed her disappointment and insisted Ronnie's rating showed he had unfinished business with Harriett.

Harriett and Ronnie left the villa together after appearing on season 11 of Love Island UK in 2024 but split weeks later, after Ronnie was accused of cheating. Their reunion in season 2 of Love Island: All Stars worried Elma, who wondered what the future had in store for her relationship with Ronnie.

Love Island: All Stars fans took to X to comment on Ronnie's rating. While many were surprised to see him give Harriett's kiss a 10 despite knowing Elma was watching, others eagerly anticipated the drama it would cause.

A fan reacts to Ronnie's score for Harriett (Image via X/ @sanaravishing)

"RONNIE GIVING HARRIET A 10 OUT OF 10???? This man is genuinely not normal Elma you are so finished," a fan wrote.

"NOT RONNIE KNOWING IT WAS HARRIET AND GIVING HER A 10," another fan commented.

"Me running to Twitter after Ronnie voted Harriet a 10 KNOWING WHO SHE WAS IN FRONT OF ELMA," a netizen tweeted.

Love Island: All Stars fans were shocked by Ronnie's score for Harriett.

"Ronnie immediately recognizing harriet with the blindfold on and still giving her a 10," a user reacted.

"RONNIE GIVING HARRIET A 10 KNOWING WHO IT WAS AND ELMA IS RIGHT THERE IS TV GOLD," a person commented.

"Ronnie rating Harriett’s kiss. 10 knowing it was her is the drama that I want and need xx," another user wrote.

"Ronnie giving the kiss from Harriett a 10 in front of Elma, he’s got to be one of the biggest villains love island has ever seen," one user posted.

Other Love Island: All Stars fans reacted to the dramatics of the situation.

"Ronnie knowing exactly who kissed him and then scoring her a 10! Is the drama we have been missing," a person reacted.

"the fact that ronnie KNEW that kiss was harriett is so hilariously iconic. love island producers knew what they were doing," another netizen commented.

---

"It's always been you" — Love Island: All Stars' Ronnie has a private conversation with Harriett

While talking to the male islanders after the challenge, Ronnie revealed he "knew straight away" that it was Harriett. He added that he could tell from the "smell" and the overall experience. The cast member confessed the kiss brought back "every feeling," making him reconsider his relationship with her.

"I thought I was done," Ronnie said.

Later in the episode, Harriett and Ronnie had a private conversation, during which Ronnie stated that the kiss "threw" him, making him feel "sick." He then spoke about his connection with Elma, noting it was not as strong as with Harriett.

While the ex-partners talked, Elma eavesdropped on their conversation from the day bed. Although Ekin-Su and Kaz advised her not to, she listened anyway.

In the meantime, Ronnie expressed that he wanted to be the "best boyfriend" he could be, confessing that Harriett's arrival brought back unresolved feelings. He admitted feeling vulnerable and surprised by the emotions that she rekindled.

"It's always been you, you know that," Ronnie said.

Harriett was not the only "bombshell" to enter the villa. Thursday's episode also saw Montel joining the remaining islanders, shifting relationship dynamics.

---

Love Island: All Stars season 2 can be streamed on ITVX.