"Im crying man!" — Love Island: All Stars fans react to Kaz confronting Casey after his arrival

Kaz and Casey from Love Island: All Stars (Images via Instagram/@kazcrossley and @caseyogorman)
Kaz and Casey from Love Island: All Stars (Images via Instagram/@kazcrossley and @caseyogorman)

Love Island: All Stars returned with a new episode on Tuesday, January 14, 2025. It showcased a heated confrontation between Kaz Crossley and the villa's latest entry, "bombshell" Casey O'Gorman, who was enthusiastic about finding love. However, that bothered Kaz, who called him a "player" without wasting much time, alleging him of mistreating his past partners, one of whom was her friend, Georgia Harrison.

Casey's entry into the South African villa marked his third appearance in the Love Island franchise. He was one of the original cast members in season 9 where he explored connections with Claudia Fogarty and Rosie Seabrook. In 2024, Casey appeared in the All Stars season to give love another try and sparked a connection with Georgia and Eve Gale.

Despite multiple failed attempts, Casey returned to the Love Island villa, hoping to make his third appearance successful. However, he received a confrontational welcome after Kaz drew everyone's attention to his flirtatious personality, alleging him of messaging every woman in the cast. Casey defended himself by dismissing her accusations as untrue, however, Kaz remained unconvinced.

Love Island: All Stars fans took to X to react to Kaz's argument with Casey. While many were shocked to see her targetting Casey right after his arrival, others praised her for standing up for her friend, Georgia.

A fan reacts to Kaz and Casey's argument (Image via X/@ilovearsenal02)
A fan reacts to Kaz and Casey's argument (Image via X/@ilovearsenal02)
"Im crying man! Kaz didnt even allow Casey to unpack his suitcase," a fan wrote.
"KAZ COMING IN telling Casey he’s a red flag as soon as he walks through the door," another fan commented.
"KAZ DIDN’T EVEN GIVE CASEY TIME TO SIT DOWN," a netizen tweeted.

Many Love Island: All Stars fans commented on Kaz's decision to question Casey right after he entered the villa.

"Lmao Casey coming in and Kaz ruining his mood instantly hahaha haha," a user reacted.
"Kaz DRAGGING Casey three business seconds into getting into the villa is what I like to see!!" a person commented.
"Casey hasn’t even been in the villa for 5 minutes yet Kaz is already onto him," another fan wrote.

In contrast, one netizen questioned Kaz's timing, wondering why she did not let Casey settle in first.

"I don’t even like Casey but very weird of Kaz to jump on him the minute he got in the villa and then says he’s taking it personally? Umm yeah? Cos it is getting personal?" one user posted.

Other Love Island: All Stars fans supported Kaz, claiming she did the right thing.

"kaz clocked casey’s tea because imagine being so desperate that you go on love island in 2023, 2024 and 2025 plsss," a person reacted.
"casey the fact that this is ur THIRD time on the show kind of proves kaz's point," another commented.

"You don't know me well enough" — Love Island: All Stars' Casey calls out Kaz for questioning his intentions

Casey arrived soon after Ekin-Su chose to couple up with Kaz's partner, Curtis. He confessed the villa felt like "home now" and added that he looked forward to mingling with his fellow islanders. However, before he could settle in and have one full conversation with the cast members, Kaz confronted him about dating "a lot of girls" outside the show.

When Casey defended himself by saying he had been enjoying his single life after his previous appearance, Kaz said:

"But, like, aside from Georgia, like, you have been with a lot of islanders and, like, that's a red flag."

She revealed that the "word on the street" was that Casey had "f****ed over a few girls." Although Casey pleaded his case, saying he was a "lover boy" who did not mean any harm, Kaz refused to believe his intentions.

While speaking to the cameras, she called him a "player" and drew attention to his "defensive" behavior, convinced he was "guilty." In the meantime, Marcel and Kas requested Kaz to give Casey time and confront him the next morning.

Later, Casey criticized Kaz for accusing him of mistreatment without knowing the facts.

"No, it's not true. That's your friend's [Georgia's] opinion on me. You don't, you don't know me well enough to give your honest opinion on me. I've met you, like, twice," he said.

The Love Island: All Stars islander disapproved of Kaz's decision to confront him the moment he entered the villa in front of everyone. However, despite his complaints, Kaz refused to budge, asking him not to take everything personally.


Love Island: All Stars airs daily at 9 pm GMT only on ITV2.

Quick Links

Edited by Raina Saha
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications