"Let it go" — The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On fans react to Aria grilling Caleb at the reunion

Aria and Caleb from The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On (Image via Instagram/@aria_dewestbrooks and @prfctstorm)
Aria and Caleb from The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On (Image via Instagram/@aria_dewestbrooks and @prfctstorm)

The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On season 3 concluded after the release of the finale and the reunion episodes on Wednesday, December 18, 2024. At the reunion, the cast reassembled to address unresolved feelings and discuss disputes. In one segment of the episode, Aria confronted Caleb about liking her Instagram stories, deeming his relationship with Mariah "fake."

Caleb and Aria spent the first half of the experiment as trial marriage partners, away from their original companions, Mariah and Scotty respectively. They immediately hit it off and found comfort in each other's company. However, they were not aligned in their emotional connection. While Aria believed they bonded emotionally, Caleb did not.

Caleb eventually reconnected with Mariah and got engaged with a wedding planned for the summer of 2026. However, while Caleb reflected on his relationship with Mariah, Aria called him out for liking her Instagram stories and blocking and unblocking her. She called Mariah and Caleb's relationship insincere, criticizing him for "lurking" on her page after getting engaged to someone else.

"You're giving off mixed signals if you're engaged and happy," Aria said.

The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On fans took to X to comment on their confrontation. While many criticized Aria for coming at Caleb after he was happy with Mariah, some criticized Caleb for not being honest about his feelings.

A fan reacts to Aria's comments about Caleb (Image via X/@_GaCutie28)
A fan reacts to Aria's comments about Caleb (Image via X/@_GaCutie28)
"So nobody mentioning how Aria had unrequited feelings for Caleb and tried to lash out on him. Girl he just wasn’t in to you on that level. You were a homegirl in his eyes. Let it go," a fan wrote.
"Aria wants to ruin Mariah and Caleb’s relationship so bad Girl, he didn’t choose you. Get over it," another fan commented.
"Okay. Imma say it. Yall are pushing this aria and Caleb thing hard. I want aria to leave that man alone. Despite chemistry it’s not you. Let it go," a netizen commented.

Many fans of The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On disapproved of Aria's behavior toward Caleb at the reunion.

"Aria is bitter, why is she trying to ruin Caleb's engagement? Aria you didn't tell Caleb how you felt, just take your L and sit down..." a user reacted.
"Aria my girl, you were really in love with Caleb. I get it and i'm pretty sure him too. But he chose Mariah. It's time to move on, please," a person commented.
"I dont like how aria came for caleb during the ultimatum. it gave vindictive, home wrecker and not over it," another fan wrote.
"aria has a misplaced pent up grudge against caleb for not choosing her. like sorry the woman he knew years before you has a stronger connection than you two," one user posted.

However, some fans of The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On called out Caleb for liking Aria's posts without Mariah's knowledge.

"We two mins in the reunion and I'm already gagged, Caleb out here watching and liking Aria's ig stories as an engaged man and you didnt tell your fiance...friendship my a** bruh. You liked the girl admit it," a person reacted.
"Ohhhh so Caleb finally admits that their was an emotional connection with Aria...and people were tryna say he was just being nice. Ray Charles saw what was going on between those two," another netizen commented.

"News to me" — The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On's Mariah reacts to Aria's revelations

Things got heated between Aria, Mariah, and Caleb during the season 3 reunion of The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On. While Caleb and Mariah discussed their road trip and plans for their impending marriage, Aria interjected asking Caleb why he was "lurking" on her Instagram page, liking her Stories and other posts.

Although Caleb tried to defend himself by saying he liked Zaina's posts too, Aria refused to believe him. She further criticized Mariah for calling Caleb every night during their trial marriage.

"To me, it looks like you don't trust him," she said.

Mariah paused Aria briefly to collect her thoughts and add to the conversation. She revealed that the revelations were new to her and difficult to process.

"The who blocking-not blocking, watching her stories, that is news to me, first and foremost," Mariah said.

The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On cast member urged Caleb to be honest. She expressed that watching the show back was difficult for her because of the contrasting feedback she received from both Caleb and Aria about their trial marriage.

Scotty chimed in on the conversation and said Mariah needed "validation of what she was feeling." He urged Caleb not to deny what happened and to take accountability for his actions.

When Mariah expressed that she felt "blindsided" after watching Caleb and Aria's chemistry on The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On, Caleb said:

"I was trying to convince myself, but even watching it back, I mean, both of you are completely correct in that there was an emotional connection. I should've been more transparent, I should've been forthcoming with that."

The Ultimatum: Marry or Move On season 3 is available to stream exclusively on Netflix.

Quick Links

Edited by Raina Saha
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications