"STAY IN YOUR LANE"— Love Island: All Stars fans divided by Scott and Luca's argument about Tina

Luca from Love Island: All Stars
Luca from Love Island: All Stars (Image via Instagram/ @lucabish)

Love Island: All Stars season 2 aired episode 13 on Sunday, January 26, 2025. The segment saw Scott and Luca clash during a Russian Roulette-inspired game of Truth or Dare, after Scott kissed Grace after admitting to Luca, Casey, and Ron that he had feelings for Tina.

The two argued and were separated by the islanders. However, when Ekin-Su dared Luca to kiss someone he believed was on the show for fame, he kissed Scott. The cast member's revelation upset Tina, who left the game in tears. Fans of the reality show commented on the argument online and viewers were critical of both cast members.

Love Island: All Stars fans react to Luca and Scott's clash (Image via X/ @ArufonsoK)
Love Island: All Stars fans react to Luca and Scott's clash (Image via X/ @ArufonsoK)
"Scott started it.... why would you wind luca up, then gaslight by saying "I'm being respectful to you" and then call him insecure and expect that luca isn't going to strike back! You know lucas mouth will run. STAY IN YOUR LANE AND YOU WONT GET RUN OVER," one person wrote on X.
"Scott pressed Luca's buttons with the "I won't even go there" re Grace's truth and Luca said "Oh you want VIOLENCE? I'll show you VIOLENCE!!" You must not know bout me, you must not know bout me Luca didn't even stop to think," a fan commented.
"scott yelling at luca?? LUCA GET BEHIND ME LET ME HANDLE THIS," a tweet read.

Some fans of Love Island: All Stars criticized Luca:

"Luca is actually so MESSY for him to spill Scott’s tea like that infront of everyone is CRAZY," a person wrote.
"He hasn’t changed and everyone thinks he has legit nobody asked for him or wanted him back on that show he’s nothing out a pot stirrer who upsets people. The fact that pepole say that he didn’t do anything wrong in season 8 is disturbing because he did on MULTIPLE OCCASIONS," a fan commented.
"#Luca really is quite a nasty person, he hurt #Tinas feelings in the process. It wasn’t his business to spill the beans. It was Scott’s business. #Luca needs to go," a tweet read.

Fans of Love Island: All Stars season 2 further said:

"Luca evidently from today’s episode and previous episodes does not like it when the guys lead the girls on or are not honest about their feelings. It’s almost like it bothers him personally. We saw it with Nas a few nights ago and Ron and Scott tonight," a person wrote.
"Luca was literally the one who came up with the plan not to tell the girls that Scott doesn’t really like Tina so he was more than okay with that actually…. plus he didn’t tell Scott to tell Tina once…. He was just making fun of the fact that he’s leading her on that’s it," a fan commented.

"That's why you're with Tina"— Luca claims Scott was on Love Island: All Stars season 2 for fame

In Love Island: All Stars season 2 episode 13, Scott opened up to several male cast members about his feelings for Tina. He told Ronnie, Casey, and Luca that something was "stressing" him out, and added that he felt that Tina was "so good" for him.

Luca told him that he couldn't help how he felt and the male islanders decided not to tell their partners about the conversation, as Scott expressed wanting to tell Tina himself.

Later in the Love Island: All Stars season 2 episode, the cast played a game of Truth or Dare during a Las Vegas-inspired party— however, things took a turn when Scott kissed Grace on a dare. When Grace landed on Truth, Scott said he didn't want to "go there" by asking her anything but Luca told him to be honest.

As the two argued, Scott took a step closer to Luca and asked him who he was talking to. The other islanders pulled the two apart and Scott asked Luca if he was "insecure." The game continued and Luca landed on a dare. Love Island: All Stars star Ekin-Su asked him to kiss someone he believed was on the show for fame.

The islander kissed Scott on the cheek and explained that he believed the cast member got to know a few people before coming into the villa. He added that Scott wanted to get "far" in the game.

"And that's why you're with Tina, and you're not feeling it," Luca added.

Tina questioned Luca's statements and said she was a "no one," while Scott criticized the male Love Island: All Stars season 2 star's statements. He said Luca was a "different breed," and Tina asked him what Scott had said about her. Tina walked away in tears while Scott wondered who Luca was.

Fans of Love Island: All Stars season 2 commented on the argument online, and while some criticized Scott, others criticized Luca and said he humiliated Tina in the process.


Tune in on Monday, January 27, 2025, to watch Love Island: All Stars season 2's upcoming episode on ITV.

Quick Links

Edited by Sukriti Makhija
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications