"WILD"— The Challenge fans react to Cara Maria and Laurel Stucky's argument

Laurel and Cara Maria from The Challenge 40
Laurel and Cara Maria from The Challenge 40 (Image via Instagram/@thechallenge)

The Challenge season 40 aired a brand new episode this week on Wednesday, September 18, 2024. The segment saw Laurel Stucky and Cara Maria Sorbello get into a screaming match, leaving the latter in tears.

Cara Maria and Michele Fitzgerald approached Laurel to discuss her dynamics with some of the other cast members. Cara criticized Laurel for arguing with Darrell and Emily and told her she might be the problem. The argument escalated and security had to intervene to separate the two.

Fans of the show commented on the argument online and were divided by the argument. One person wrote on X:

"Welllll...... We all knew Cara and Laurel would end up like this right? But security stepping in is WILD!"
"This Cara vs Laurel has nothing to do with the game no more. Though Laurel is the 1 that shouts more or insults & comes up as more aggressive,I feel she’s actually hurt by whatever Cara did to her. Cara started w a smirk & ended up actually hurt too?" a fan commented.

The Challenge season 40 fans criticized Laurel during the fight:

"Cara said it. @laurelstucky is very insecure and her nasty attitude in her mind is her way of thinking she is in control, but it makes her look even smaller," a person wrote.
"The way Laurel said I was on your side and they show clips from 13 years ago.. did she once have her back? Yes. has she in the last 4 seasons they have been on.. Bffr Laurel is so insecure that she turns in to a monster when anyone threatens her “strength," a tweet read.
"Quick question for the class, how can Laurel say “I’ve always been there for you” but she threw Cara in literally the first second she got this session….weird behavior," a fan commented.

The Challenge season 40 fans criticized Cara Maria:

Cara literally opened the door for this fight. Mind your f**king business. Her and Michelle’s convo was done, why are you including yourself and using this moment to address Laurel??? Get a grip!" a person wrote.
"I love Cara but how they edited made it seemed like she came @ Laurel, which I don’t like Laurel but Cara shouldn’t of came @ her singling her out just like what happened to her in the past. Idkk I still love Cara. Maybe it was just the editing," a fan commented.
"Poor Cara she was so amped and went in all tough but ended up crying. She actually really needs to ignore Laurel, the only option I fear," a tweet read.

Laurel and Cara Maria get into a screaming match in The Challenge season 40 episode 5

In The Challenge season 40 episode 5, Cara Maria and Michele Fitzgerald approached Laurel to talk about her constant arguments with some of the other cast members. Cara Maria told her that she might be the problem.

Laurel told the season 40 star that she was the problem. Cara Maria yelled at her and said she wouldn't "back down" to her anymore and Laurel said that all The Challenge star did was "scream."

"I personally think Cara is just childish and in a state of an adolescent mind and I'm doing everything that I can to avoid the situation that is basically about to explode," Laurel said in a confessional.

Laurel told Cara Maria that she was "unaware" while the latter pointed out they were the only ones who didn't "f*ck with each other" in season 40. She added that Laurel was being an "a**hole" to everyone in the house. Laurel responded by calling The Challenge Battle of the Eras star "manipulative." Cara said she "started it" and Laurel called her a "13-year-old."

Laurel said Cara Maria would push her to her "breaking point" and made a comment about Cara's boyfriend, Paulie. The latter said that her boyfriend "actually had her back," and Laurel said she also had her back. Cara yelled that she also had Laurel's "back" in The Challenge: All Stars 4.

"This is about a game? This is about All Stars 4 because I beat you? Because I beat you in All Stars 4? Don't you f***ing say that about me because when it comes down to it, I am with you," Laurel yelled.

Security personnel intervened and separated the two. Laurel walked away while several cast members consoled Cara Maria.

Fans chimed in on the argument online and were divided in their opinion. While some criticized Laurel, others felt Cara Maria shouldn't have approached her.


The Challenge season 40 will air episode 6 next week on MTV.

Edited by Sukriti Makhija
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications