"Worst nightmare come true"— The Traitors US fans react to Dorinda Medley's murder

2024 People And NBCUniversal Upfront - Source: Getty
Dorinda Medley at the 2024 People And NBCUniversal Upfront (Image via Getty)

The Traitors US premiered season 3 on Thursday, January 9, 2025. Three episodes were released, showcasing the players suspecting one another while hoping to make it through the night without getting "murdered." However, not everyone could avoid the traps of the Traitors. One such cast member was Dorinda Medley, who was "murdered" in the second episode.

The Traitors— Bob the Drag Queen, Danielle Reyes, and Carolyn Wiger— decided to "murder" The Real Housewives of New York City's former star Dorinda to break apart the huddle of Housewives on the show. However, Carolyn's initial target was Robyn since her elimination would help them use Dorinda as a cover shield.

The first episode showcased Dorinda locking horns with Lord Ivar Mountbatten regarding the results of the first challenge. Bob the Drag Queen told his co-conspirators that they could utilize their feud to frame Ivar for Dorinda's murder. It would not only send a Faithful home but also prevent others from suspecting them.

However, The Traitors US fans were unimpressed by the conspirators' decision to eliminate Dorinda. They took to X to vent their frustration about her "murder," claiming she deserved to stay in the game.

A fan reacts to Dorinda's murder (Image via X/ @isbyeathreat)
A fan reacts to Dorinda's murder (Image via X/ @isbyeathreat)
"One of the worst first boots ever, losing Dorinda this early on in the game is my worst nightmare come true. We were deprived of so much future entertainment. I’m heartbroken," a fan wrote.
"We don’t get to see the mess of Dorinda at a roundtable oh this is hell," another fan commented.
"they murdered dorinda WAY too fast i’m so upset," a netizen tweeted.

Fans of The Traitors US were upset to see Dorinda leave the competitive reality show so early.

"Dorinda being the first faithful to be murdered… I just need a minute…" a user reacted.
"Which stupid a** producer thought it was a good idea to eliminate Dorinda first," a person commented.
"Dorinda first boot over Dolores? Like put on our thinking caps????" another fan wrote.
"Absolutely devastated to have lost Dorinda at the first murder. She’s the epitome of drama, she’s loud & serves entertainment just by breathing, & she already gave us a fight on Night 1! It’s a shame people won’t get to see more of her. I’ll miss her presence!" one user posted.

Other fans of The Traitors US expressed a similar sentiment.

"Dorinda really got f**king murdered and sent home first . She was my favorite going in and I’m so mad like i genuinely started crying," a person reacted.
"What, they killed Dorinda, then these are some idiot #Traitors. Sorry, not sorry. That just makes no logical sense to disrupt the group?!? No other housewife has the skill to really work as a traitor, you idiots," another netizen commented.

"I can't believe it" — The Traitors US star Dorinda reacts to her murder

When the cast gathered for breakfast the following morning, they immediately noticed Dorinda's absence and realized she was "murdered" in the quiet of the night. Meanwhile, Dorinda was brought to a separate room where she was handed the official decree. Once she realized what had happened, she said:

"I can't believe it. Oh, my biggest fears have come true."

After reading the decree, the former star of The Real Housewives of New York City confessed she was disappointed by the decision. She believed she already had a target on her back because of her "strong character." Although Dorinda knew it could unsettle many, she refused to apologize, saying she could not help but be her genuine self.

Fellow Housewife Dolores Catania was equally upset by Dorinda's elimination. While reacting to her exit, Dolores said:

"It is so terrible to lose a friend so early, and a good friend!"

The Traitors US star praised Dorinda's confident personality, saying Dorinda was never afraid to speak her mind. Meanwhile, The Real Housewives of Potomac star Robyn stated she was not surprised by Dorinda's "murder." She knew the Housewives had a target on their backs since they were "talkative" and the "center of attention."

Elsewhere, Bob the Drag Queen and Danielle acted shocked and emotional at the breakfast table to prevent others from suspecting them.


The Traitors US airs new episodes every Thursday at 9 pm ET, exclusively on Peacock.

Quick Links

Edited by Raina Saha
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications