"She was bummed" - The Traitors season 3 star Wells Adams shares his wife’s reaction to his exit

Wells Adams, the Bachelor in Paradise bartender, became the first contestant eliminated from The Traitors season 3 during the premiere episode on January 14, 2025. After the episode aired, his wife, Sarah Hyland, watched the elimination unfold the following morning. In a detailed interview with Entertainment Weekly, Adams revealed his wife's candid reaction.

"She wasn't super proud of me," Adams shared. "I mean, there's vows that we said for better or worse, so she can't divorce me over this. She was bummed, I think. She ended up watching it this morning. I'm like, 'What did you think?' And she was like, 'Yeah, you don't look that bad.' I'm like, 'It's that bad, isn't it?'"

He continued:

"I think she thought that I would win. I thought that I would win, and then I didn't. So here we are."

The elimination occurred during the first Roundtable session after the Dragon Boat mission, where Adams became the target of fellow players.

---

Wells Adams shares what Sarah Hyland said about his quick exit from The Traitors

The Traitors season 3 elimination story began during the season premiere's Dragon Boat challenge. As contestants gathered for their first mission, Adams stepped up as a leader, steering the vessel. This visibility quickly drew attention from other players, particularly Real Housewives of Potomac star Robyn Dixon.

During the crucial first Roundtable, Dixon voiced concerns about Adams' demeanor after host Alan Cumming selected the Traitors. Her observation sparked a chain reaction among contestants, leading to an increased focus on Adams' behavior.

Despite his background as a seasoned reality TV participant with over 150 episodes of experience, Adams couldn't overcome the mounting suspicions. The majority vote sealed his fate, making him the first banished contestant. Upon revelation as a Faithful, Adams executed his planned slow clap exit, turning the moment into a memorable scene.

The Modern Family actress absorbed the episode's events the following morning, her reaction mixing support with disappointment. Behind Hyland's measured response lay genuine surprise at the outcome. Both she and Adams had anticipated a stronger showing in the competition, given his experience reading people during his time as Paradise's bartender.

---

Wells Adams's elimination process in The Traitors season 3

Adams' strategy crumbled within seven hours of filming. The Traitors season 3's first Roundtable session transformed Adams' game from strategic player to first elimination. His background as Paradise's bartender, spanning over 150 episodes of reading contestant behavior, did not shield him from suspicion.

Dixon initiated concerns by noting changes in Adams' demeanor after the Traitor selection. His explanation about conserving energy during non-filming moments, a habit from his radio host days, failed to convince fellow contestants. The varying energy levels between filmed and unfilmed segments raised red flags among players.

When they cast the votes, the majority chose Adams for banishment. Adams concluded his brief game run with a slow clap exit, drawing from classic 90s movies for his final moment.

After elimination, in an interview with NBC Insider, Wells stated,

"No one had an idea of who to vote for, and so everyone was kind of pointing fingers at everybody else, and that's why it came down to that weird vote."

The Traitors season 3 star continued,

"And that's why it looks really confused because the one person that we all were locked in on, they got rid of. I think what happened was everyone said, 'Well, I don't want to be banished, and I see that people are going after Wells. I'll just write down Wells' name.'"

In the end, his status as a Faithful player revealed The Traitors season 3 group's first incorrect judgment. Adams concluded his brief game run with a slow clap exit, drawing from classic 90s movies for his final moment.

---

The Traitors season 3 is airing on Peacock Network.