Episode 5 of The Traitors US season 3, All This Murderous Power, aired on January 23, 2025, on Peacock. The episode picked up after Rob Mariano’s decision to eliminate fellow Traitors Bob the Drag Queen, creating tension within the Traitors group.
Rob’s actions caused mistrust with Carolyn Wiger and Danielle Reyes, while Wes Bergmann, a Faithful, grew suspicious of his gameplay. During the Traitors’ meeting, Rob, Carolyn, and Danielle debated their next target, considering Sam Asghari, Gabby Windey, and Robyn Dixon.
Despite Carolyn’s frustration with Rob, they agreed to eliminate Robyn. At breakfast, Robyn’s absence confirmed their decision, and Lord Ivar Mountbatten warned Carolyn that Rob was drawing attention, especially from Wes.
The mission this week involved solving riddles for cash and a chance to earn shields for protection. Meanwhile, Sam Asghari spoke up for the first time at the Round Table, warning that Rob’s survival could be a major problem.
The Traitors debate targets as tensions rise in episode 5
The Traitors, Rob, Carolyn, and Danielle, met to decide their next murder target. Rob explained his reasoning for targeting Bob D.Q., stating it was necessary to maintain his position. Carolyn, however, questioned his motives, calling it an “ego thing.” Carolyn said,
"I don’t trust you. I don’t want you here. I’m sick of his a*s."
The group considered eliminating Sam Asghari, Robyn Dixon, or Gabby Windey. Carolyn and Danielle preferred Gabby, but Rob pushed for Robyn, saying the chaos another Housewives elimination would create.
Eventually, Robyn was selected as the target. At breakfast, her absence confirmed the murder, and Carolyn learned from Lord Ivar that other players, like Wes, were beginning to piece together Rob’s game. Lord Ivar noted that Rob’s confident actions at the Round Table had painted a target on his back.
"The way he went after Bob so confidently absolutely put a big target on his back," Lord Ivar said.
On the other hand, players speculated on potential Traitors. Nikki Garcia faced suspicion due to Gabby’s survival, while Wes attempted to build a narrative against Rob. Danielle, meanwhile, suggested the idea of targeting Carolyn, aiming to recruit a new Traitor in her place if successful.
Round table strategies and Sam’s warning
As this episode of The Traitors progressed, during the Round Table, conversations shifted between Rob, Nikki, and Ciara Miller as potential targets. Rob defended his actions, stating,
“Once Bob D.Q. started deflecting, it was clear he was a Traitor.”
To which Sam Asghari said, “If he’s not dead tonight, then I’m on him tomorrow … for sure,” hinting his growing suspicion of Rob.
Nikki became the focus after Chrishell Stause pointed out her shift in behavior following Bob D.Q.’s elimination. Chrishell explained, after Bob D.Q. left, she felt an "energy shift" in Nikki. Nikki denied the accusations, stating,
“People will have assumptions about me, but I’m willing to let them vote based on that.”
The vote resulted in Nikki’s banishment, with the majority of players agreeing to send her out. Afterward, Derrick Levasseur confided in Wes Bergmann, saying, that he was certain Rob was a Traitor, while Dylan Efron privately informed Carolyn that Danielle Reyes had suggested her name as a potential target.
Fans can watch the new episodes of The Traitors season 3 airing every Thursday at 9/8c on Peacock.