Who went home tonight on The Great British Bake Off 2024? Details Explored

The Great British Bake Off's episode 3 aired on Tuesday, October 8, 2024. The third episode saw John Mincher, being eliminated from the competition.

The show's popular Bread Week, involved the remaining 10 bakers battling through a series of challenging tasks, including the Signature, Technical, and Showstopper rounds.

Despite his previous strong performances, including being the first Star Baker of the season, John was eliminated after a tough round of bread-making. Host Noel Fielding delivered the news, marking the end of John’s journey in the tent.

John, a 37-year-old directorate support manager from Willenhall, reflected on his elimination, saying,

"It's fine – it was expected... it was just a bad week." He added, “The tears are tears of pride.”

Following the eliminations of Hazel Vaughan and Jeff, Mincher became the third contestant to leave The Great British Bake Off tent.

---

The Great British Bake Off: John's elimination and details explored

John's "Yamas!" Savoury Buns in the Signature round were critiqued for having dry textures and large steam pockets. Later, he faced further challenges in the Technical round, placing ninth in the seven-strand plaited wreath challenge, which lacked the precision and finesse the judges expected.

The Showstopper round further sealed John’s fate. His 'Horn of Pride' cornucopia impressed with its colors and shine, but the underproof and flavorless buns, coupled with over-proofed bagels, didn’t meet the high standards of the judges. It was ultimately this combination of setbacks that led to his elimination.

Reflecting on the difficulty of the competition, John said,

“Because everybody is so talented, if you drop the ball, it’s your time to go.”

Despite the disappointment, he took pride in his previous achievements on The Great British Bake Off.

---

What happened in the third episode: Bread Week recap

Bread Week on The Great British Bake Off featured several challenging tasks for the bakers, all centered around perfecting different types of bread. The Signature Bake required the bakers to create 12 identical savory buns.

Judges Paul Hollywood and Prue Leith were looking for good structure, stretchy dough, and, most importantly, delicious flavors.

Several bakers rose to the occasion. Dylan Bachelet, a retail worker from Buckinghamshire, earned the coveted Star Baker title despite being placed last in the Technical challenge. His Gochujang & Garlic Savoury Buns earned him a Paul Hollywood handshake, a significant achievement in Bread Week.

Dylan’s 'Cat' cornucopia in the Showstopper round further impressed with indulgent flavors and a sturdy structure, ensuring his top spot for the week.

The Technical round, however, proved to be particularly tricky. Bakers were tasked with creating a seven-strand plaited wreath, with instructions delivered live by Paul Hollywood himself. Nelly excelled in this challenge, taking first place, while Sumayah also performed well, redeeming herself after a tough Signature round.

The Showstopper, a grand Bread Cornucopia Display, brought out the best and worst in the bakers. While Nelly and Dylan received high praise for their creative and flavorful displays, others struggled with technical flaws and flavor issues.

Andy’s 'New York, Neeeeeew York!' cornucopia and John’s 'Horn of Pride' failed to meet expectations, contributing to John’s elimination.

---

The Great British Bake Off Series 15, Episode 4 will air on Tuesday, October 15, 2024, at 8 pm BST on Channel 4 and is also available for streaming on Channel4.com.