'%20x='0'%20y='0'%20height='100%25'%20width='100%25'%20%0A%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20xlink%3Ahref=''%3E%3C/image%3E%3C/svg%3E)
The offscreen drama in the world of The Real Housewives of Orange County (RHOC) often rivals the on-screen action. This was notably evident in 2018 when Jim Bellino, ex-husband of former RHOC star Alexis Bellino, pursued legal action against Tamra Judge and Shannon Beador.
The lawsuit stemmed from comments RHOC stars Judge and Beador made during a podcast that Bellino claimed was defamatory and damaging to his business. The lawsuit generated substantial public and media interest due to the high-profile nature of the individuals involved and the detailed accusations made.
The background of Bellino's lawsuit against RHOC stars Tamra and Shannon
Alexis and Jim Bellino's split
Trending
Alexis and Jim Bellino's marriage was a notable storyline on RHOC, with Alexis leaving the show five years before their June 2018 split. After 13 years of marriage, they announced their separation, stating there were no scandalous reasons for their decision.
In a joint statement to Us Weekly in June 2018, they expressed:
“Outside of the news of our decision to part ways, there is nothing provocative, alluring, or sordid about the dissolution of our marriage. Quite to the contrary, we strongly support each other just as we have since the beginning of our relationship.”
The alleged defamatory remarks
Following the announcement of Alexis and Jim's split, Tamra Judge and Shannon Beador appeared on Heather McDonald’s Juicy Scoop podcast. During the podcast, they made several comments about Jim Bellino that led to the lawsuit. According to court documents obtained by Us Weekly, Judge mentioned:
“He was very crusty … I almost sent [Alexis] a message saying so sorry and then you sent me that text going ‘Do you think that he’s like trying to protect her … Do you think possibly that he’s in trouble, you think she can’t testify against him, he’s in trouble and all that stuff and I’m like oh that’s a whole ‘nother story."
Additionally, Judge referred to Jim as a “shady mothaf—ka” and claimed he was “going to jail.” Meanwhile, Beador added that “people get paralyzed” at Jim’s trampoline park, another comment that Bellino found highly defamatory.
After the podcast aired, Jim Bellino sent cease and desist letters to Tamra Judge and Shannon Beador, accusing them of making "morally corrupt" comments about him. When they refused to retract their statements, Bellino filed a lawsuit on July 27, 2018, seeking over $1 million in damages. He claimed their remarks were defamatory and harmed his business.
The legal battle and developments
Initially, both Tamra Judge and Shannon Beador dismissed Jim Bellino's lawsuit, asserting their comments were meant in jest and not to be taken seriously. They reiterated this stance during a July 2018 appearance on Watch What Happens Live, emphasizing that they were "just poking fun" at Bellino and his ex-wife, Alexis.
However, unconvinced by their explanation, Bellino proceeded with the lawsuit. By September, both defendants had submitted legal responses urging the court to dismiss the case, arguing their comments were protected under free speech and not defamatory.
The lawsuit became more complicated with the involvement of former RHOC star Gretchen Rossi and her partner Slade Smiley. Bellino claimed in September filings that Rossi and Smiley could testify to the anger and hostility Judge and Beador had towards him, demonstrating a pattern of behavior aimed at fabricating stories for media attention.
Judge sought to block Rossi from testifying, calling the motion "foundationless" and "hearsay." Bellino, meanwhile, demanded Judge provide texts and emails with podcast host Heather McDonald, believing they would show intent to defame him. Judge argued her statements were opinions, not facts. Bellino insisted the comments were defamatory, damaging his reputation and business, prolonging the legal battle.
Particularly, Bellino insisted that Judge’s description of him as a "shady mothaf—ka" was presented as a factual claim rather than an opinion, making it critical to his defamation claim.
Outcomes and case dismissals
Shannon Beador ultimately won her case against Jim Bellino after a judge dismissed his lawsuit against her in January 2019 and ordered him to pay her legal fees. Beador was awarded $137,340.25 of the $220,000 she sought for her legal defences. Beador expressed relief over the decision in an interview with People in October 2020, saying:
"I am grateful and relieved because this has taken an emotional and financial toll on my family."
However, Bellino’s legal challenge did not end there. Although Beador’s case was closed, Bellino’s lawsuit against Tamra Judge remained active. Bellino's lawyer mentioned to PEOPLE:
"We are disappointed with the court of appeal's ruling as it pertains to Ms. Beador, but nevertheless pleased that the court at the same time ruled that Mr. Bellino's defamation case against Ms. Beador's co-defendant, Tamra Judge, should go forward."
Judge's continued legal struggle was highlighted in an episode of RHOC in December 2019, where she expressed frustration over the financial burden imposed by the lawsuit. She recounted the emotional and monetary strains the lawsuit caused, stating that over $300,000 had been extracted from her bank account due to the ongoing legal issues.
RHOC co-star Kelly Dodd's involvement also added to her distress, as Dodd had offered to be a character witness for Bellino, which she later apologized for, admitting she intended to harm Judge.
Get ready for more drama, excitement, and unforgettable moments with the cast of RHOC! Season 18 of RHOC is heating up, and you won't want to miss a single episode. Tune in every Thursday at 9 p.m. ET on Bravo to catch all the latest twists, turns, and explosive confrontations.
