5 chilling details about the case of Sarah Saganitso

Out There: Crimes of the Paranormal is a Hulu series that unearths the intersection of the paranormal and real-life crimes, like the case of Sarah Saganitso. Season 1, Episode 6, titled The Shape-shifting Defense investigates the unsettling 1987 murder of Sarah Saganitso, a Navajo woman from Flagstaff, Arizona.

In 1987, Sarah Saganitso was a 40-year-old Navajo mother and long-time housekeeper at Flagstaff Medical Center. Her routine change to the evening shift raised family concerns for her safety, especially after encountering a suspicious man at work. On June 12, after finishing her shift around 11 pm, Sarah went missing.

The following morning, search efforts led by her alarmed family and hospital security found her body in a wooded area near the hospital. She was discovered nude, with her death caused by strangulation and evidence of severe physical assault, including bite marks and lacerations, suggesting a violent encounter.

Initial police investigations were criticized for their slow response. Despite the family's immediate suspicion and provision of potential leads, including a list of people who could be involved. The police focused on an ex-boyfriend, who was later cleared with a verified alibi.

The investigation then shifted toward George Abney, a local poet and professor who confessed about the murder, to a priest. He claimed a sudden blackout during his interaction with Sarah Saganitso led to the fatal event describing his actions as a confused expression of past traumas. His trial introduced claims of coerced confession and cultural misconceptions about shape-shifters, leading to his acquittal.

---

5 most harrowing details about Sarah Saganitso's case

Noir (Image sourced from Unsplash)

1) Unexpected shift change and security concerns

Sarah Saganitso had been working the day shift at Flagstaff Medical Center for years, allowing her ample time with her family in the evenings. The sudden switch to the evening shift not only disrupted her routine but also raised major security concerns and the change occurred just before her murder that intensified her vulnerability.

Sarah and her siblings were so concerned for her safety that they memorized her new schedule to ensure she returned home safely each night.

---

2) Encounter with a suspicious man

Weeks before her tragic death, Sarah Saganitso reported an unsettling encounter with a strange man at her workplace, which left her feeling threatened. The incident led her to take extraordinary security measures, including keeping defensive tools like a hammer, screwdriver, and knife within easy reach at her home and in her vehicle.

The level of preparedness shows the real and perceived threats she faced daily and spotlights the heightened state of alert that marked her final days.

---

3) Discovery of the body

Sarah Saganitso’s body was found in a wooded area near the hospital which is a location close yet secluded enough to raise questions about the perpetrator's familiarity with the area. The state in which she was found was particularly distressing: nude, with evident signs of a brutal assault.

The lacerations and bite marks on her body suggested a violent struggle and a cruel disregard for human dignity. The location and condition of her body point to the calculated brutality of the attack, reflecting a grim scene that investigators and her family were confronted with.

---

4) Police response and investigation delays

Still of a building interior (Image sourced from Unsplash)

The initial response from local law enforcement to Sarah Saganitso’s disappearance was marked by significant delays. Her family’s urgent pleas for a quick search were met with procedural hesitations, as officers stated they could not take action until she had been missing for over 24 hours.

The delay in the investigation could have cost crucial hours in gathering evidence or possibly preventing the tragic outcome. The subsequent handling of the case including overlooking potential suspects suggested by the family added to the frustrations and feelings of helplessness among her loved ones.

---

5) The confession and trial of George Abney

George Abney’s involvement in the case brought a perplexing twist. After a priest relayed that Abney had confessed to knowing details about the murder, he was interrogated and eventually confessed to the killing, claiming a blackout during the attack.

His trial, however, unveiled arguments about coerced confessions and cultural misunderstandings regarding Navajo shape-shifter myths. Despite forensic evidence linking him to the crime, the defense’s narrative about mental health and cultural myths led to his acquittal.

---

Out There: Crimes of the Paranormal can be streamed on Hulu.