5 chilling details about Jerry Hancock's murder 

Jerry Hancock turned out to be the victim of a family dispute that took a deadly turn in Charleston, South Carolina. A once-ordinary household became a battlefield when his feud with his stepfather, Gene Capps, spiraled beyond control.

Although it was just all about a feud over a sandwich, it ended in a brutal murder, shocking the quiet neighborhood and bringing an eternal devastating memory to the family.

Airing on November 13, 2024, at 10 p.m., the episode titled Vicious Cycle dives into the tragic unraveling of Jerry Hancock's family as a minor grievance escalated into irreversible violence.

The case hinges around the strained relationship between Jerry Hancock and his stepfather, Gene Capps, who cohabited under a convoluted arrangement. Hancock was to purchase the property for $210,000, permitting Capps and his spouse to reside there until their demise.

As property values escalated, tensions increased, prompting Capps to seek a renegotiation of the terms. The precarious foundation of mistrust and anger ultimately culminated in violence, revealing the grim truth of unresolved familial conflicts.

Here are five haunting details about Hancock’s murder, highlighting the fragile, dangerous nature of unaddressed anger and tension.

Disclaimer: This article contains the writer's opinion.

---

Chilling factors about Jerry Hancock's murder

1) A dispute over a sandwich became the final straw

Dispute over sandwich turned into a murder. (Image via Unsplash)

One of the most unsettling aspects of Jerry Hancock's murder is the apparently insignificant trigger: a half-eaten sandwich. Following months of strain and numerous disputes, a disagreement regarding a sandwich drove Capps to his limit.

A trivial disagreement escalating to murder underscores the profound unresolved issues within the family. The minor provocation highlights how swiftly minor irritations can escalate into catastrophic consequences when resentment festers beneath the surface for an extended period.

---

2) Four shots to the head in cold blood

Four shots to the head in cold blood (Image via Unsplash)

Capps' act of shooting four bullets into Jerry Hancock's head represents a chilling level of cold-blooded resolve. The accuracy and brutality of the act, witnessed by Hancock's mother, illustrate a chilling depiction of how violence can manifest in moments of unrestrained fury.

The calculated brutality astonished investigators and the community, as it evidenced Capps ensuring Hancock's demise with no possibility of survival. The repeated gunfire signified an alarming intensity of rage.

---

3) The murder happened in front of Hancock’s mother

The murder happened just in front of Hancock’s mother (Image via Unspalsh)

The tragedy of Jerry Hancock's murder is exacerbated by the fact that his mother, Catherine Hancock Capps, was a witness. This detail adds a profound emotional burden to the case, as she was compelled to witness her son's brutal demise at the hands of her husband.

The psychological burden she bears from the brutal loss of her son exacerbates the horror of the situation. The personal connection makes the murder not merely a crime but a profound tragedy for the entire family, with repercussions that transcend the immediate act of violence.

---

4) A history of alleged abuse with no evidence

Hancock's murder (Image via Unsplash)

Capps' claim that Jerry Hancock was abusive was one of the main things that led to the fight. According to police, Capps' claims weren't supported by any evidence, but the claim continued to fuel the anger.

The constant accusations made by Capps reveal a deep-seated anger that ruined the family's relationship, letting personal grudges take precedence over logic. This false story made Capps even angrier, and it all came to a deadly head-on collision. This shows how false stories and assumptions can lead to terrible outcomes.

---

5) A life sentence avoided despite the brutality

A life sentence avoided despite the brutality (Image via Unsplash)

The most disconcerting aspect of Jerry Hancock's murder is the legal resolution. Despite the egregious nature of the offense, Capps evaded a life sentence. He ultimately entered a plea of guilty to voluntary manslaughter and received a sentence of merely 20 years in prison.

Circuit Judge Roger Young remarked that, in his opinion,

"You got away with murder, if you ask me".

Capps’ defense attorney argued for a suspended sentence, highlighting that any time spent in prison would effectively serve as a life sentence for the elderly client due to his declining health.

Initially, Capps faced murder charges following the January 5, 2019, shooting that claimed the life of 51-year-old Jerry Hancock. This outcome has left many questioning the justice of the sentence, as it seems disproportionately lenient, given the gravity of the crime.

---

Feuds Turned Fatal: Vicious Cycle airs on November 13, 2024, at 10 p.m., on Investigation Discovery.