Lauren Giddings, a 27-year-old Mercer University law graduate, was murdered in June 2011 in one of Macon, Georgia's most shocking cases. She disappeared, and days later, dismembered body parts were found in a dumpster a few blocks from her home.
A suspect who was shockingly close to her and a string of unsettling details that had come to light during the investigation made the case blow into nationwide attention. Dateline: The Smoking Gun: The Watcher featuring this case, aired on Thursday, October 31, 2024, at 8:00 pm on Oxygen True Crime. Here are five of the most chilling aspects surrounding Lauren Giddings' murder.
5 shattering facts about Lauren Giddings’ murder
1) The discovery of Lauren Giddings' dismembered torso
Lauren Giddings went missing on June 29, 2011, when friends and family couldn't contact her. They searched her apartment and found her belongings, including her purse, keys, and laptop, suggesting she hadn't planned to leave. They called the police, who noticed a strong odor near a trash bin outside the apartment.
Police later traced the smell to a giant bag containing Giddings' torso dismembered. The remains of her limbs and her head were never discovered. The torso was the very first sign of what that young law graduate must have suffered through in terms of extreme violence. This find alone sparked an intense investigation into what must have done to her.
2) Blood evidence found in Lauren Giddings' apartment
Forensic analysis within Lauren Giddings' apartment presented evidence of a crime perpetrated with extreme violence. When the police sprayed a luminol chemical that revealed traces of blood-they found the bathroom drenched with a lot of blood residue, especially around the bathtub.
Blood traces almost reach the top of the tub, indicating that she might have been brutally dismembered in her apartment itself. The crime was too well-planned, leaving very few signs in other places in her apartment. This heinous evidence led the investigators to the people around her, particularly her neighbors and classmates, as suspects.
3) Suspicious behavior of neighbor Stephen McDaniel
One of the most unnerving aspects of the investigation was how Lauren's classmate and neighbor, Stephen McDaniel, appeared throughout it. At the beginning of the inquiry, when word of Giddings' disappearance hit the television stations in Carrollton, McDaniel was interviewed and appeared almost tearful as he denied ever knowing anything about his neighbor.
Just a short time later, he was approached while being filmed and was told that Lauren's torso was found. During the same interview, he got completely catatonic and had many erratic expressions on film that made one suspect and also made him a possible person of interest in this murder.
As detectives dug deeper into McDaniel's background, they discovered that he had a history of disturbing behaviors and was obsessed with Giddings, even watching her several times through her apartment window. His behavior before and after the murder was a key component in bringing investigators to their conclusion that he was indeed her killer.
4) Evidence found in McDaniel's apartment
A search of McDaniel's apartment was conducted and found some products that would indicate a shocking obsession and possible preplanning. A hacksaw, with traces of blood around it, was discovered as well as women's underwear which Giddings did not possess, and two keys- which opened Giddings' apartment.
A further search for any online activity of McDaniel revealed some disturbing internet history. He had been searching for dismemberment, body decomposition, and violent videos. Detectives found hidden videos on his laptop showing that he had secretly recorded Giddings through her window, revealing his obsession with her.
This collection of evidence pointed to McDaniel as a prime suspect.
5) McDaniel's confession
Stephen McDaniel was arrested and charged with first-degree murder in August 2011. He pleaded not guilty to the crime, but in 2014, overwhelmed by a mountain of evidence under a plea bargain, he confessed to the murder. In his confession, McDaniel revealed that he sneaked into Giddings' apartment in the dead of night on June 26, 2011, to execute his plan.
He told them he strangled her and then dismembered the body in the bathtub of her apartment. McDaniel's confession offered gory details that corresponded to what had been discovered; it would spare Giddings' family from an ordeal of an interminable trial. McDaniel accepted his plea and was given life imprisonment but would be paroleable after 30 years.
His plea agreement finally answered some of the questions regarding the tragic end of Lauren Giddings, although the confession is one of the most chilling aspects of the case.
Dateline: The Smoking Gun, airs on Thursdays at 8/7c p.m. on Oxygen.