Kimberly Dowell and Ethan Dixon were two teenagers from Muncie, Indiana, whose lives were cut short in a double homicide that has remained unsolved for almost four decades. Their case, often referred to as the Westside Park Murders, occurred in September 1985 and continues to haunt the local community and true crime enthusiasts.
The case has been the topic of books, podcasts, and continuing conversations, illustrating its influence and the questions left unanswered. Both victims were students at Muncie Northside High School and had no reported criminal association. They were discovered dead in Dixon's car at Westside Park, which was a local hotspot.
Although there have been extensive investigations into many theories, no one has ever been charged with their murders. The case was covered by Crime Junkie podcast in their latest episode titled, The Westside Park Murders. The episode was released on April 28, 2025, and is available on numerous platforms.
Five important facts regarding the murder of Kimberly Dowell and Ethan Dixon
1) The Westside Park crime scene

Multiple sources indicate that the murders occurred late at night in September 1985 at Westside Park on the White River in Muncie, Indiana. Kimberly Dowell and Ethan Dixon were discovered in the front seats of Ethan's Volkswagen Rabbit hatchback, which was still running when found by a police officer making his rounds around the park at its closing time. One of the windows on the car was open, and a gunshot shattered the other.
The scene had reportedly been startling enough that the officer had to momentarily pause before calling in backup. Kimberly Dowell and Ethan Dixon had been shot dead, and the motive behind the attack could not be discerned from the evidence at the scene.
2) The victims were local students with no criminal connections
Kimberly Dowell and Ethan Dixon were both students at Muncie Northside High School—a junior and a senior, respectively. As reported by accounts, they were popular and familiar in the community. Their inactivity in known criminal behavior also added to the shock and perplexity of the case.
The killings received instantaneous attention in Muncie, spreading rapidly among friends, family, and schoolmates even before the reports were published in local newspapers the following day.
3) The investigation led to numerous suspects but no arrests

The Westside Park Murders investigation was thorough and involved a large number of law enforcement personnel at its height, including 19 officers at one point. According to reports, early suspicion centered on a relative of one of the teens, but this line of inquiry did not lead to charges being filed.
As per reports, investigations also looked into a broad array of other theories, ranging from a random murder to a botched drug deal, personal targeting, or even the work of a serial killer. The case went cold over the years as leads evaporated, and no solid evidence was discovered.
Years later, a determined investigator allegedly narrowed the investigation to one suspect, but the identity of that individual has not been disclosed to the public.
4) Theories and community impact
As per WRTV, there have been investigations into various theories put forth regarding the motive and killer. Even outlandish suggestions, such as role-playing games like Dungeons and Dragons, were investigated and dismissed by law enforcement.
Reportedly, the case also had a lasting effect on the Muncie community, undermining the feeling of security of the residents and instilling fear regarding crime and corruption within the city at the time.
The book The Westside Park Murders: Muncie's Most Notorious Cold Case by Douglas Walker and Keith Royson, both of whom were veteran journalists, discusses these hypotheses and the larger context of the city's past through interviews with the detectives, the victims' friends, and family members.
5) The case remains unsolved
As per WRTV, even after decades of research and investigation, the killings of Kimberly Dowell and Ethan Dixon continue to be unsolved. There has been no one charged in connection with them, and it remains a cold case on law enforcement's records.
As per published reports, hope for closure continues, but the absence of fresh evidence has kept the case open, and the victims' families still look for answers.
The 1985 double murder of Kimberly Dowell and Ethan Dixon is one of the lasting mysteries of Muncie, Indiana.