'%20x='0'%20y='0'%20height='100%25'%20width='100%25'%20%0A%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20%20xlink%3Ahref=''%3E%3C/image%3E%3C/svg%3E)
Marcus Rutledge was a 23-year-old college student who disappeared in June 1998 in Nashville, Tennessee. His case remained unsolved for more than two decades, but in early 2025, his remains were identified.
The circumstances of how he left and how he was murdered have created a story of complexity and questions. This case was covered in the Crime Junkie podcast episode titled MURDERED: Marcus Rutledge, released on February 10, 2025.
Five key details about the murder of Marcus Rutledge emphasize tragic events in his life and death
1) Disappearance and initial investigation
Trending
According to Oxygen, Marcus Rutledge was last seen on June 8, 1998, when he dropped his daughter at daycare. He was supposed to meet his girlfriend, Tawania, but when Tawania could not reach him that evening, she called his family.
Can prime numbers be dangerous? More about Apple TV+'s new conspiracy thriller HERE
His family reported Marcus missing after finding evidence that he did not intend to be gone long, such as a pet dog he had taken in, which was left in his apartment. His car was found abandoned weeks later at an apartment complex, but initial leads ran dry.
2) Discovery of the remains
According to NBC News, in December 2010, a hunter reported finding a human skull within a wooded area of Ashland City Highway and Pecan Valley Road. This was one of the most pivotal moments in the case.
Over the years, the skull had not been identified and became popularly known as Pecan Valley John Doe until it was conclusively identified as being that of Marcus Rutledge through DNA evidence in January 2025. This identification restored renewed interest in the case and the circumstances of his death.
3) Suspicions of foul play
According to News Channel 5 Nashville, the Metropolitan Nashville Police Department suspects foul play in the disappearance and death of Marcus Rutledge. His family had long feared that something terrible had beenfallen him.
At this juncture, when his remains were identified, David Rutledge expressed the hope that his son's fate and the identity of those involved would now be known to them. The police are still probing into the case, urging everyone with information to come forth.
4) Secrets and personal struggles
According to Oxygen, as the case unfolded, Marcus was found to have been concealing information from his family. He had been reported to them as attending Tennessee State University but was later revealed to have left school.
More so, he was selling marijuana to sustain himself and his baby girl. This led many to wonder whether these activities led to his disappearance and murder.
5) The impact on family
According to News Channel 5 Nashville, his father, David Rutledge, expressed that the call from detectives in January 2025 confirming Marcus's remains were found was both a relief and a source of sorrow. He had long hoped for news that Marcus was alive, but instead, he learned of his son's tragic fate.
"Whoever hurt Marcus took a son from his mother and father and a father away from his then two small children," David stated.
He emphasized the loss felt by Marcus's children who believed he had simply walked away.
As the investigation continues, it can be hoped that answers will emerge regarding what truly happened to Marcus Rutledge on that fateful day in June 1998. For more details on the case, listen to the Crime Junkie podcast.
