Critics divided over Netflix’s The Madness as it secures a lukewarm score on Rotten Tomatoes

Netflix's latest thriller series, The Madness, premiered on November 28, 2024, and has garnered a mixed response from critics, earning a lukewarm score on Rotten Tomatoes. Starring Colman Domingo as Muncie Daniels, the eight-episode series is directed by Stephen Belber

The plot follows Daniels, a media pundit, who becomes involved in a murder investigation while on a trip to the Poconos. In his journey to clear his name, he reconnects with estranged family members and confronts personal dilemmas.

The Madness currently holds a score of 69% on Rotten Tomatoes, based on 13 critic reviews. This score suggests that the show had its strengths, but may not have appealed to everyone.

The divided opinions are rooted in its execution of themes, pacing, and character arcs. While some praised its unique approach, others felt the series lacked cohesion or depth in its storytelling.

The audience response has been just as divided as critical reception. On X, one fan wrote:

"6 episodes in. I wanted to like this show so bad but the writing is wack and the plot is #The Madness- good actors, bad decisions at every turn - the jokes and stereotypes just don’t fit - most scenes feel like fillers - 8 episodes could have been 4.”

On the other hand, another fan on X wrote:

"#TheMadnessNetflix was 10/10"

---

What critics and audiences are saying about The Madness

Screenshot of the Rotten Tomatoes score (via Rotten Tomatoes)

Reviews on Rotten Tomatoes reveal contrasting views. Collider praised the series, stating:

"Every one of its pieces comes together to successfully create a poignant, thrilling, highly watchable series."

The publication also praised Colman Domingo's portrayal of Muncie Daniels as a highlight of the series. Similarly, RogerEbert.com commended Domingo's performance, noting

"The Madness is another reminder of the range and power of Colman Domingo, Oscar-nominated last year for 'Rustin' and hopefully again this year for 'Sing Sing.' A thriller like The Madness only works if we believe the journey of its protagonist, and Domingo completely closes the sale."

In contrast, Slant Magazine critiqued the show’s narrative structure, stating:

"More disappointing is how jumbled the show’s political commentary becomes...It’s an artificial balancing of the scales that ultimately prevents the series, which is ostensibly about the courage to speak truth to power, from saying anything meaningful at all.”

The publication added that the series didn’t fully deliver on its themes, leaving viewers with more questions than answers.

The Observer noted:

“Sorry to star Colman Domingo, but the ever-changing villains, already dated takes on politics, and nonsensical set up make this show just about unwatchable."

Variety stated that while the series showcased moments of brilliance, they were overshadowed by inconsistent plot developments.

Rotten Tomatoes has featured reviews from fans and audiences as well. Here are some reviews fans wrote for The Madness:

User Mendy M writes:

“Domingo’s deep voice and strong screen presence are highlights, though even his talents can’t salvage a script that fails to rise above mediocrity.”

Another user Muriel W wrote:

“Please do not pay attention to any negative reviews. This is an excellent crime/drama/thriller. The characters are well rounded, and the plot builds consistently throughout the limited series. Let’s give credit where credit is due. This is well written, well directed, and a well crafted story to follow.”

Another fan said:

“The start was promising but after the first episode, things get murky and less credible. And I lost interest.”

These comments highlight the polarized reception of the series, where some viewers appreciated its ambition and thematic depth while others found it lacking in execution and originality.

---

Concluding thought on The Madness

Still from The Madness ( via Netflix)

The Madness is currently available for streaming on Netflix. The series has a unique premise that encourages viewers to think deeply about its themes. Colman Domingo’s performance has been praised for adding depth to the narrative.

The show blends suspense with elements of drama, creating a storyline that aims to keep the audience engaged. However, both critics and viewers have shared mixed opinions about the series.

While some have appreciated its exploration of moral dilemmas and personal struggles, others feel that the execution could have been more consistent. Whether you resonate with its themes or critique its execution, The Madness invites viewers to draw their own conclusions.