5 Chilling details about Justin Rutherford's crimes 

Justin Rutherford was a doctor who held a shocking criminal secret (image via Unsplash)
Justin Rutherford was a doctor who held a shocking criminal secret (Image via Unsplash)

Justin Rutherford is the subject of the popular true-crime podcast Betrayal. Rutherford was a family doctor convicted of sexual assault of minors and the invasion of privacy in 2021. He is serving his prison term at the State Correctional Institution in Albion, Pennsylvania.

Season 3 of the true-crime podcast Betrayal delves into the story of Justin Rutherford, a happily married doctor with a family who turns out to be a devious predator. The eight-episode podcast was released on May 23, 2024, and the final episode was streamed on July 11, 2024. Follow the article to learn about the chilling details of Rutherford's crimes.


5 Most shocking details about Justin Rutherford's crimes

1) Rutherford led a double life, and his wife and children were clueless about his crimes

As discussed in the Betrayal podcast, Justin was a respected doctor in Berks County, Pennsylvania. He met his wife, Stacey Rutherford, when he was a medical student. Stacey was a single mother, and the pair settled down in Amity Township, Berks County, where he worked as a family doctor at Tower Health. Justin's family was clueless about his dark deeds, and they lived a picture-perfect life till his arrest.


2) He used a hidden camera in his bathroom to record undressed people

The doctor recorded unsuspecting victims for years before being caught (Image via Unsplash)
The doctor recorded unsuspecting victims for years before being caught (Image via Unsplash)

A 13-year-old boy uncovered a secret camera in Justin's bathroom while showering. When he reported it to the police, they investigated and tracked the camera back to Justin since he was the owner of the house. It was uncovered that Justin Rutherford recorded 2800 videos and 1400 still pictures of people undressing without their consent. Many of the videos and pictures were of underage children and teenagers.


3) He sexually abused two teenagers

When the police investigated Justin's crimes, more victims came forward (Image via Unsplash)
When the police investigated Justin's crimes, more victims came forward (Image via Unsplash)

When Justin was first arrested in 2021, two male teenagers came forward, accusing Justin of sexually assaulting them. One of the victims was a 17-year-old who alleged that Justin intoxicated him and then physically assaulted him. The other boy was a 16-year-old who claimed that Justin had been exploiting him for over five years.


4) Rutherford planned to get one of his victims killed

Rutherford planned the murder of one of the witnesses against him (image via Unsplash)
Rutherford planned the murder of one of the witnesses against him (image via Unsplash)

In a twisted turn of events, Justin Rutherford tried to get the 16-year-old victim killed to remove him as a witness. Justin planned the murder when he was under police custody. He planned the murder through a phone call from prison and even instructed the other person to wear gloves and proper clothing to avoid his DNA from being left at the crime scene.

Luckily, the police intercepted the calls and prevented the murder from taking place. However, this plan added to Justin's list of crimes as he was also charged with criminal solicitation to commit first-degree murder.


5) Justin Rutherford has been sentenced to a long prison term

A file picture of Justin Rutherford in custody (Image via Berks County District Attorney)
A file picture of Justin Rutherford in custody (Image via Berks County District Attorney)

Rutherford pleaded guilty to r*pe of an unconscious person, r*pe of a child, invasion of privacy, and sexual abuse of multiple children in October 2022. The plea was non-negotiable, and he was sentenced to prison for 26 years 10 months to 70 years, followed by 12 years of special probation.

Initially, Justin's wife, Stacey, was also named a defendant in his crimes; however, she absolved herself and her children by establishing no prior knowledge of his crimes.


Betrayal Podcast Season 3 can be streamed on iHeart, Apple Podcasts, and Spotify.

Quick Links

Edited by Ivanna Lalsangzuali
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications