Law and Order season 24 episode 13 recap: A plea deal brings resolution to a difficult case

NBC's Law and Order season 24 episode 13 premiered on February 20, 2025. The latest episode of the police procedural drama focuses on the murder of a young lawyer with a secretive past. As the investigation unfolds, the culprit is identified, but the prosecutors struggle with bringing him to justice because of his affluent family and religious ties.

As Law and Order season 24 episode 13 progresses, Price and Baxter fight to get the murderer punished for his crimes, while the culprit's lawyer pushes for alternative justice options. In the end, the prosecuting team uses the culprit's fiancé's reputation as leverage to make him take the plea deal. They succeed, bringing resolution to a difficult case.

Disclaimer: The article ahead contains spoilers for Law and Order season 24 episode 13.

---

Law and Order season 24 episode 13: A plea agreement helps bring closure to Eli Freeman’s murder

In Law and Order season 24 episode 13, a wellness check leads the Law and Order team to the murder of Eli Freeman, a dedicated and secluded lawyer. Eli's body is found at his apartment, and the only person in Eli's personal life that the team can interrogate is his ex-girlfriend, Angie.

Angie leads them to another woman, Martha, who was seen having lunch with Eli before his death. After digging up Eli's background, the police uncovered that Eli was born Elijah Penner and was part of a religious community called Baylor Church up until he was 17. He had severed ties with the Church because of its strict regressive values years earlier.

Martha is a woman from the same community, and she soon becomes central to the case. She had been secretly meeting Eli despite being engaged to Jake Albrecht, a man from the same church. When detectives dig deeper, they discover Martha is pregnant with Eli’s child, and during interrogation, Jake reveals that he knew about Martha's affair and he killed Eli.

However, his confession is thrown out due to his family's connection and his status in the church. Jake's father offers that he will pay for his sins by doing community service. With limited options, Price and Baxter use Martha’s pregnancy as leverage to pressure Jake into accepting a plea deal.

Jake loves Martha, and to prevent her from being scrutinized by the church, he agrees. This brings an end to the case in Law and Order season 24 episode 13.

---

Jake's close-knit church comes in the way of justice in Law and Order season 24 episode 13

In Law and Order season 24 episode 13, Eli Freeman's past connection with the Baylor Church plays a central role in his murder. Eli had an affair with Martha, and Martha is engaged to Jake Albrecht, another member of the Baylor Church and the son of the head pastor.

When Jake learns about Martha’s secret meetings with Eli, he confronts him at his apartment. He believes that Eli is trying to take Martha away from him and the community, and he murders him.

Despite knowing the truth, the Baylor Church members rally together to protect Jake. Key witnesses, including Eli’s mother who sees Jake washing bloodstained clothes the night of the murder, refuse to testify against him.

The members fear the consequences of going against their leader and his son and are afraid of being shunned by the community. The church’s influence nearly derails the case, with Jake’s confession being dismissed due to his pastoral status. However, Price and Baxter's efforts ensure that justice is delivered by the end of this week's episode.