Law & Order season 24 episode 19 recap: What was Sofia's real identity?

Law and Order airs on NBC on Thursdays (Image via X/@lawandordertv)
Law & Order airs on NBC on Thursdays (Image via X/@lawandordertv)

Law & Order season 24 episode 19, titled Play With Fire Part 1 aired on April 17, 2025. The latest episode of the police procedural drama features a case that begins with an ICE raid and ends with a deep dive into systemic failures, past trauma, and the pursuit of justice. When a young woman known as Sofia is found murdered, the investigation uncovers a disturbing pattern and a personal connection to Captain Olivia Benson.

Ad

In Law & Order season 24 episode 19, the victim Sofia's real name is Maria Recinos, a rookie cop inspired by Benson after she saved her from child trafficking years earlier. She first appeared in the season 7 episode 13 titled 9-1-1. She was later seen in season 25 when she entered the police academy. In this episode, she was working undercover trying to catch a s*xual predator.


Law & Order season 24 episode 19: Sofia’s murder leads to a shocking discovery

Ad

Law & Order season 24 episode 19 opens with an ICE raid on a homeless shelter that sends undocumented migrants fleeing for safety. Two women manage to escape, agreeing to reunite at a hostel, but only one makes it. The other, known only as Sofia, is later found burned in an oil drum at a warehouse. Her friend, Ana, calls a number Sofia trusted, Captain Olivia Benson. Benson answers, but the call ends abruptly before she learns who is at the other end.

Ad

The case falls under Homicide’s jurisdiction, led by Detective Riley, with support from SVU. Lieutenant Brady connects it to a two-year-old case with a similar M.O., where a young woman named Rosa was found the same way. Brady had once arrested a man named Carlos for Rosa’s murder, but new evidence clears him, revealing she’d been wrong.

As the team investigates, they learn Sofia had been staying at a shelter run by Father Alberto and was close to Ana. Eventually, Sofia’s true identity is revealed. She was Detective Maria Recinos, an undercover rookie trying to expose a predator exploiting undocumented women. Her murder unravels a trail of trafficking, false leads, and another victim, Ana. The case leads the team to search for the real killer still at large.

Ad

Law & Order season 24 episode 19: Maria's death connects to a case from the past

Ad

In Law & Order season 24 episode 19, Detective Maria Recinos, posing as Sofia, was murdered while investigating a man exploiting undocumented migrant women by promising fake visa help. The case echoes an earlier unsolved homicide, Rosa, a migrant woman found burned in an oil drum two years ago.

Lieutenant Brady arrested Carlos, a man she believed was the killer, only to discover later that he was innocent. He had an alibi for both murders, prompting painful self-reflection for Brady. Maria had learned about Ana’s assault at a warehouse and, without backup, went there hoping to catch the predator. Instead, she was ambushed and killed.

Ad

SVU and Homicide tracked her steps and uncovered a trafficking ring. They rescued twelve women being held captive, but still hadn’t found the murderer. Eventually, DNA at the crime scene led to Miguel Pinto, a known r*pist. However, surveillance footage cleared him as well, he was being framed.

When Ana was brought in for questioning, she mysteriously vanished from the precinct, only to be found strangled soon after. Maria’s investigation revealed two predators operating in parallel, one a trafficker, the other a serial killer. Her dedication helped dismantle the trafficking ring, but her murder remains a reminder of a past case mishandled and justice delayed.

Ad

Stay tuned for more updates on Law and Order season 24.

Quick Links

Edited by Sezal Srivastava
Sportskeeda logo
Close menu
WWE
WWE
NBA
NBA
NFL
NFL
MMA
MMA
Tennis
Tennis
NHL
NHL
Golf
Golf
MLB
MLB
Soccer
Soccer
F1
F1
WNBA
WNBA
More
More
bell-icon Manage notifications